ITPRO

Printed from www.itpro.co.uk

Register to receive our regular email newsletter at http://www.itpro.co.uk/reg/register.

The newsletter contains links to our latest IT news, product reviews, features and how-to guides, plus special offers and competitions.

Skip to navigation

    Head to Head: Windows 7 vs Windows Vista

7 vs vista

By Benny Har-Even, 4 Nov 2009

Rating: $rating

In our latest head to head, Windows 7 faces its immediate predecessor, Windows Vista. Will Vista be able to mount any kind of challenge?

Features

Windows Vista offered a number of features that set it apart from its predecessor. The Network Map view gave a clear indication of the layout of your network, and it had better support for encrypted networks, and newer standards such as WPA2. It also tells you if you’ve connected to the network but have lost internet access and it offered native support for IPV6 for the first time in Windows.

Vista also added some enhanced networking features over XP, with some clear ways of breaking down permissions in the Network and Sharing Centre.

However, as we outlined above, Windows 7 made it even easier to deal with networks. Windows 7 adds the entirely new Home Group feature – that lets you easily share media – though only between Windows 7 machines, which sort of implies that you’re going to be filling your house with Windows 7 kit. If you do have a couple of Windows 7 machines though it does make sharing much easier.

Windows 7 also adds the ability to burn an ISO directly from the operating system and you get power features such as PowerShell IDE built-in too.

For the office, you also now get Direct Access so you can tie into the office network without having to bother with VPNs.

Windows 7 also adds Remote Media Streaming, which lets you play your Windows Media Player files over the internet, and it also offers Play To, which lets you push music to Windows 7 machines around your house, office or home office.

In Vista, memory performance was enhanced through the use of SuperFetch, we gained ReadyBoost that let you boost performance just by putting in a memory stick. It also promised enhancements with ReadyDrive, with hybrid hard disks – standard drives with additional flash memory, though these never really took off – and since then full SSDs have started to enter the mainstream.

One of the new features in Windows Vista was the instant search ability to launch programs directly from the Run box – removing the long Windows XP programs list that when filled with too many apps quickly became unwieldy. This is much better in Windows 7 though, as it’s much more granular. In Vista only the main programs can be accessed this way, but in Windows 7 you can find specific parts of the operating system, such as the control panel – so most things you want to do can be done just by typing.

You can also link in third-party searches into Windows 7 to external sites using a feature known as Federated search.

Email to a friend

Print this page

3 comments

You need to Login or Register to comment.

I am running Vista Ultimate and feel...

ripped off by Microsoft because ... [we] never received the extras we paid good money to get," said "Hellfire" in a long comment. "The very least that they should do is offer a heavily-discounted upgrade to Windows 7 Ultimate to those that have lost money by purchasing Vista Ultimate.... (quote itworld)

By JaKowal on Wednesday Nov 4

1 people out of 1 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

Lack of drivers & problems with older applications

I bought a new machine and dual booted with XP and Vista 64. XP wouldn't install on SATA only system and had to slipstream (combine drivers and services packs onto a DVD). Vista 64 wouldn't work with some of my perpherials like a serial A4 graphics tablet and there where no update drivers for scanner and film scanner and no support for video and TV hardware. The support came for some things 18 months after launch, but was lacking for others. In upgrading to Windows 7 (leaving XP alone) it hung for 4 hours with no indication of what it was doing. All the software had to be installed again, even though this was W7 64 Ultimate over Vista 64 Ultimate. Most of the software to be installed would not run. There are no SCSI drivers, even for current Adaptec cards, no drivers for a current HP printer and it is hard to find a method to enable installation as Vista 64. Having installed and fixed compatibility to XP SP2 the application prompts for permission everytime it is run. Never did that in Vista. The background for Vista was okay, neat. The W7 is terrible. I have switched it to plain, making it more like my XP screen. Over all this was the hardest upgrade to install since Windows 3 days before drivers where on the internet. It would seem the age old advise for products from M$ remains true - don't get any until at least the first service pack.

By Ip_gfge5146c4406 on Friday Nov 6

0 people out of 0 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

No version of Windows can be purchased

@Benny Har-Even: "with its relative affordability, free alternatives have lost some of their lustre..." Let's get this straight once and for all, one can only buy a *licence* to run a copy of a Windows OS, one can never *own* a copy. In contrast to this abomination, a user always *owns* their copy of the "free alternatives" to which you refer.

By 6tricky9 on Friday Nov 6

0 people out of 0 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

    You may also like...

advertisement
advertisement

    Whitepapers

Want more background on today's hottest IT trends?

Visit IT PRO's whitepaper library for more on virtualisation, encryption and other topics.

    Register for IT PRO

You'll get exclusive member benefits including free whitepapers, downloads, Webinars and weekly newsletters full of the latest IT PRO news, reviews, insight and expertise.

Advertisement