ITPRO

Printed from www.itpro.co.uk

Register to receive our regular email newsletter at http://www.itpro.co.uk/reg/register.

The newsletter contains links to our latest IT news, product reviews, features and how-to guides, plus special offers and competitions.

Skip to navigation

    TomTom for iPhone with car kit review

tomtom iphone

By Benny Har-Even, 24 Nov 2009

Rating: $rating

Price as reviewed:£99 inc.VAT plus £59.99 for UK and Ireland maps

TomTom's long awaited car-kit for the iPhone has been released. In this review, we take it for spin to see if it's worth the outlay.

We’ve covered the app itself in our first look, but it’s worth a recap. The app delivers a very familiar look and feel to any standalone TomTom device, which is great but it also feels like a native iPhone app – with menu layout and button placement as you would expect on the iPhone.

Navigation is very easy indeed. The default screen shows a 3D view of your location and you simply tap the screen anywhere to bring up the menu from where you can select the navigate menu to route straight to your Home location, to a saved favourite, a recent destination, or to a post code. You can plan in advance so you don’t need an active GPS signal for work out a route in advance, and as the entire maps are located on your iPhone, you don’t need a data signal to start with. Despite the large data set the app starts up relatively quickly on an iPhone 3GS in less than 10 seconds.

car kit

In use, we found the routing to be effective. The app also takes advantage of TomTom’s IQ routes, which draw data from thousands of user journeys – and as such you’ll get the most effective route for the time of day. The apps also warned us of approaching speed cameras with a chime.

When an incoming call is received, the map disappears to be replaced with the phone screen, but audio instructions still continue from the speaker. When the call ends, the map auto resumes.

We read many complaints of the position indicator on the TomTom app lagging behind the actual location, but we didn’t experience this in our tests. Recent updates to the app may have helped in this regard, and the SirfStar III chip in the car kit appears to be doing its job.

While we found ourselves perfectly happy with the usability and performance of the TomTom app, we were frankly surprised at the lack of features compared to standalone devices. With the x40 Live series in 2008, TomTom added the Google Local Search feature that enabled you to find where you wanted to go via a Google search, and then route to it. It seems like a no-brainer to include it in a data device such as the iPhone, but surprisingly it’s not present. As such, you’re limited to using the included Points of Interest database, which while comprehensive is clunkier than a simple Google search.

Email to a friend

Print this page

Sat Nav : Reviews

2 comments

You need to Login or Register to comment.

So where's the benefit?

Let's say I have an iPhone and a bluetooth hands-free kit; now I need Sat-Nav. My options - £158 for a solution that runs on my iPhone or a dedicated Tom-tom for less. I've had an integrated solution before and the observation that the map disappears for an incoming call reminds me of the time that happened approaching a complex junction on the edge of Leeds - several miles and many minutes later I was eventually back going the right direction! Sorry - not convinced!

By CoxJul on Friday Nov 27

3 people out of 3 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

Correction

Your first paragraph must be incorrect because both TomTom and CoPilot work on the 3G as well as the 3GS. A compass is most useful when walking or stationary, but is not essential for turn-by-turn navigation and is often not a feature of stand-alone units. Apple's ban on turn-by-turn must have either been commercial, or perhaps the realisation that it would just highlight the shortcomings of the built-in GPS.

By JohnHind on Friday Nov 27

2 people out of 2 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

    You may also like...

 Sponsored Links

advertisement

    You may also like...

    Latest Sat Nav Analysis & Insight

Space

How much is space worth to Britain?

A new report suggests the space industry could add £40 billion to the economy - but it needs investment and better organisation first.

Read more

 
advertisement

    Register for IT PRO

You'll get exclusive member benefits including free whitepapers, downloads, Webinars and weekly newsletters full of the latest IT PRO news, reviews, insight and expertise.

Sponsored Links
Advertisement