Sheffield student faces extradition over 'piracy'
By Tom Brewster,
A student accused of breaching piracy laws is facing extradition to the US, where he could get up to five years in jail.
Sheffield Hallam student Richard O'Dwyer, the 23-year-old behind the TVShack website, lost his case at Westminster Magistrates' Court, but his lawyer indicated an appeal would be made.
US authorities believe TVShack, which O'Dwyer's lawyer Ben Cooper claimed hosts links to content rather than the actual content itself, breaches copyright laws.
The case was brought by the US Customs and Border Protection agency and no criminal charges were lodged by British authorities. TVShack was shut down by US authorities.
A 19-year-old British kid built a search engine, gets sued by US Government and is now fighting extradition to USA.
O-Dwyer's mother, who told the BBC she was not fully aware of what her son's website did, said Britain's extradition treaty with the US was "rotten."
Some from the tech industry have expressed their opinions over the case on Twitter.
"A 19-year-old British kid built a search engine, gets sued by US Government and is now fighting extradition to USA," said Mikko Hypponen, chief research officer at security firm F-Secure.
The case comes at a time when the Government is under pressure from MPs to review how it handles extradition hearings.
An independent review of the UK's current extradition arrangements carried out by Sir Scott Baker in 2010 claimed the current treaty between the US and the UK was fair.
However, the Joint Committee on Human Rights has called on the Government to renegotiate the UK-US agreement to ensure UK citizens get equal treatment to Americans.
The case of Gary McKinnon, who was accused of hacking into US military and NASA systems, continues as he also looks to avoid extradition.
You may also like...
Sponsored Links
advertisement
You may also like...
Latest Public Sector Analysis & Insight
The Digital Economy Act: Is it doomed to never happen?
As a further delay hits part of the implementation of the Digital Economy Act, is this just a small hiccup, or is the Act being rendered toothless already? Simon Brew takes a look.
- Does the government want to snoop on your data?
- Q&A: Rajeeb Dey, CEO Enternships
- Government IT: Apples for the mandarins
- Striving to solve the security skills crisis
- 2011: The year in news
- Are the cookie laws crumbling already?
- UK rural broadband: too little, and too late
- How the Data Protection Act's death will punish the UK economy
- Education: glad to be a geek
Latest Public Sector Reviews
HTC Flyer review: First Look
- HP TouchPad review: First Look
- RIM BlackBerry PlayBook review - First Look
- MWC 2011: Acer Iconia A100 and A500 reviews – first look videos
- MWC 2011: HP TouchPad review - first look video
- MWC 2011: RIM BlackBerry PlayBook review - first look video
- MWC 2011: HP Pre3 review - first look video
- MWC 2011: Motorola Pro review - first look video
- MWC 2011: HTC Flyer tablet review - first look video
- MWC 2011: Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 review – first look video
advertisement
Most popular
- UK regulator shuts down Angry Birds scam
- Apple iPad 3 vs iPad 2 head-to-head review
- IBM bans use of Siri on iPhones
- Chromebooks: What's gone wrong?
- HP plans massive job cuts
- EMC World 2012: Tucci declares Documentum is here to stay
- Dell EqualLogic PS6100XS review
- Macs and Android under malware threat
- RIM loses its head of sales
- Local fibre broadband needs common standards
Latest News Videos in Public Sector
Q&A: David Elton, PA Consulting Group
CIOs are increasingly influential, but have to juggle "dual roles", study finds.
Register for IT PRO
You'll get exclusive member benefits including free whitepapers, downloads, Webinars and weekly newsletters full of the latest IT PRO news, reviews, insight and expertise.






Different rules
Strange that they refused to extradite Fergie to Turkey saying that she hadn't broken any laws in the UK, but a different rule seems to apply to O'Dwyer. Is it because it's the US, or is it because he's not titled?
By Smiler10 on Tuesday Jan 17
RE:
I think the safest thing for him to do now is disappear off the radar. Just let his parents know he'll be safe, fresh PAYG at each end for contact, and leg it.
By MartinP on Wednesday Jan 18
The UK->US Extradition Program
if destination=US then extradite=yes
else goto fair-hearing
end if
By MartinP on Wednesday Jan 18
If hosting 'links'......
...to content is breeching the U.S. copyright laws and you can be extradited and tried by a foreign nation whilst, technically, breaking no laws within their jurisdiction - then why haven't Facebook, Youtube and, more pertinently, Google been shutdown and prosecuted under the same laws ?
By cidermark on Wednesday Jan 18
If hosting 'links'......
...to content is breeching the U.S. copyright laws and you can be extradited and tried by a foreign nation whilst, technically, breaking no laws within their jurisdiction - then why haven't Facebook, Youtube and, more pertinently, Google been shutdown and prosecuted under the same laws ?
By cidermark on Wednesday Jan 18