ITPRO

Printed from www.itpro.co.uk

Register to receive our regular email newsletter at http://www.itpro.co.uk/reg/register.

The newsletter contains links to our latest IT news, product reviews, features and how-to guides, plus special offers and competitions.

Skip to navigation

    A data shock warning for Orange customers

Orange didn't tell Tom Brewster he was going to lose his data bundle. Here's why it has made him angry...

By Tom Brewster, 17 Jan 2012 at 17:06

Orange

COMMENT The first data shock is the deepest. At least that's how I feel following my first encounter with an unfeasibly high data bill.

Like any upstanding technology journalist, I regularly check my mobile bills, just to ensure there aren't any unaccountable charges. So when I saw a £33 charge for data in a month where I did not download any apps nor use the internet excessively, I was a tad baffled.

Thrust into this state of bewilderment, and with a face redder than Steve Ballmer on a bad day, I grabbed my mobile and dialed up Orange's minions demanding they tell me why they were going to suck away more of my measly funds than usual this January.

The customer service employee even agreed it wasn't particularly helpful practice.

What I learned was both infuriating and hugely concerning for Orange customers. Ironically, it is older, more loyal Orange customers who should be most anxious.

What had happened, I was duly informed, was that my contract had finished. This meant the data bundle was taken off of it, yet I was still on the same voice deal. Therefore my bill for just 257.2293MB of data stood at £33.20. In previous months data had cost me nothing. Already I was perturbed as to why this was the case.

Perhaps I should have kept on top of matters better, but at no point had I been warned this would happen. I had received no calls advising me to change contract, nor any guidance from Orange whatsoever on the issue. Maybe this pernicious little proviso is kept hidden in small print I should have read somewhere, but the fact that I was not forewarned is more than frustrating. It gets worse though.

I was told by the - admittedly very helpful - Orange customer service employee that people with older deals were not warned their contracts were coming to an end, nor were they told they would lose money-saving data bundles. Yet those with relatively new contracts (he didn't divulge exact dates) would get such a warning. Why is there a difference? Why punish older, possibly more loyal customers? I, nor Orange, appear to have much of an idea. Shocking. The customer service employee even agreed it wasn't particularly helpful practice.

I also understand T-Mobile, now part of the same company as Orange under the Everything Everywhere umbrella, does inform customers their contracts are close to their end. Bemusing, no?

Now, I have been promised £50 in credit. Yet I will still have to pay a £65.24 bill this month. For anyone who can just about live within their means, such a charge is incredibly irritating. It certainly makes my life harder this month, but I wonder how people who have even lower wages than myself or those who've recently been made redundant would feel if faced with similarly exasperating circumstances? At least it won't happen again in the future. To me, anyway...

At the time of publication, Orange's press team had not responded to a request for more information on my situation.

Oh and in case you didn't notice, Orange increased the cost of monthly plans by 4.34 per cent from 8 January. Good times.

UPDATE Orange have confirmed they do not forewarn customers that their contracts are coming to a close. The company said it had carried out research indicating customers preferred not to be bothered.

Strange then that T-Mobile lets customers know. Perhaps when Orange is no more and is fully part of Everything Everywhere it will change its position.

Orange said it was currently reviewing the matter, however, so changes could come sooner. The company is yet to confirm whether businesses are treated the same as consumers.

One wonders why Orange do not simply let the customer decide whether they want to be informed or not. If it did that, Orange would avoid upsetting certain curmudgeonly people like myself.

Email to a friend

Print this page

< Previous   Mobile : Analysis & Insight Next >

10 comments

You need to Login or Register to comment.

Legal basis for this?

Surely if the contract has come to an end Orange do not have any basis on which to charge you for the use of their services? How can they unilaterally decide what they will charge you in the absence of any agreed tariff? This is a question which should formally be asked of them. It all smacks to me of unfair practice against which you do have some legal protection.

By ncollingridge on Friday Jan 20

29 people out of 31 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

We should all go GiffGaff

Need better service, better control of your account and excellent value for money then go GiffGaff. No I'm not paid to say that and yes I do have an account with them.
I just can't wait until my O2 business account is up in May and then all my accounts will be out of contract and under my control.

By xercron on Friday Jan 20

3 people out of 7 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

(Too) Sharp Practice?

This smells uncommonly like a wheeze to garner a 'windfall' bonus from the unwary. Can it be classed as windfall if you have to shake down the tree to obtain the fruit?

By Shorty on Tuesday Jan 24

2 people out of 2 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

We should all go to Giffgaff? Don't rush.

I'm on Giffgaff and my son's on Giffgaff. For 2 months in a row now I've had to to buy vouchers from the Post Office to top up because their online system is rejecting my credit card. Everywhere else accepts it and Giffgaff accept that it's their fault. They claimed to have fixed it the first month but it's still happening. They have good aims, good coverage and packages that suit both of us ("just a phone" vs Smartphone) but they're not quite up to speed yet.

By merlin on Tuesday Jan 24

2 people out of 3 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

T-Mobile

Actually T-Mobile are guilty also, of not informing end of contract. I was caught by the back in November and had a heated debate with them asking why I was not informed. Hmmmm do we have Customers Service anymore?

By veryfriendlee on Tuesday Jan 24

2 people out of 2 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

Not a new problem

Orange have been doing this for certainly the last 2 years or so, as i had the same problem maybe 6 months ago, as it has been discussed on many a mobile forum. However, i asked the charge to be removed, and the data package put back on and it was without question, which lead me to believe they were used to this request.

I personally think it's designed to catch out those not paying attention to their bill, which isn't a very a nice way to treat trusting customers ! I personally expect them to honour their contractual obligation, while i honour mine, unless they wish to renegotiate at the end of the contract, at which point they would need to contact me.

The mildly amusing thing is they actually benefit from letting your contract run as is, as it is likely that the newer contracts are better value for you as the customer, and you are potentially still subsidising a handset which you have not upgraded to ( your monthly charge includes a handset subsidy, if you do not upgrade then you will pay if for no benefit, this is why SIM free contracts are dramatically cheaper ).

By englishpunk on Tuesday Jan 24

2 people out of 2 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

No improvement

Orange appears to be hardening its line here - arguing that the data bundles are somehow non-contractual 'loyalty bonuses'. These can be removed at will or expire after 18 months (both, according to the agent I spoke to, though clearly it can't BE both). But it's also part of a 'contract' but no, they can't send a copy of that contract.

Certainly, they have so far refused to waive the data charge on my account or return me to the previous bundle which included the data. Apparently the billing agents can't do that, only "upgrades". Read into that what you will.

Looking at my bill and those of others, it does seem they are applying charges for something that people were told would be free or included as a bundle as long as they maintained that tariff.

A promised call in "10 minutes", 3 hours later, hasn't materialised.

As a SIM only customer, I may just walk away...

By Stephen_Pritchard on Sunday Jan 29

1 people out of 1 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

Another example of Orange sharp practice

Orange raised their prices within 6 weeks of my signing a "fixed-price" 24-month contract. They also forgot to tell me that half of my monthly 600 talk minutes do not qualify for free voice mail access, as "bonus" minutes are excluded from the right to voice mail.
Both of these, plus the example in the article, seem to show a corporate attitude of tricking the customer into paying more. Can't Orange make enough money simply by being straight and honest with people?

By John_Morris on Tuesday Mar 13

0 people out of 0 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

Another example of Orange sharp practice

Orange raised their prices within 6 weeks of my signing a "fixed-price" 24-month contract. They also forgot to tell me that half of my monthly 600 talk minutes do not qualify for free voice mail access, as "bonus" minutes are excluded from the right to voice mail.
Both of these, plus the example in the article, seem to show a corporate attitude of tricking the customer into paying more. Can't Orange make enough money simply by being straight and honest with people?

By John_Morris on Tuesday Mar 13

0 people out of 0 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

An Hour of Haggling

My other half fell foul of this after inheriting my old smartphone. I've just spent an hour haggling to get a refund on the data charges. Managed £105 - eventually after a few distraction tactics.
First: "I can only do the most recent month"
Second: "The most I can do is £75"
Third: "We can't process more than one refund per day"
Finally: We won't pay the exact amount because that would an admission, but as you've been so loyal we'll go nearly all the way.
Result = £105 out of £109 - close enough.

By sadgit on Sunday Apr 29

0 people out of 0 found this comment useful.

Did you find it useful?

    You may also like...

 Sponsored Links

advertisement

    You may also like...

    Latest Mobile Tutorials

How to avoid unwanted audio alerts in iOS 5

How to avoid unwanted alerts in iOS 5

Avoid embarrassing interruptions from unexpected iPhone alerts by following Julian Prokaza’s guide to configuring iOS 5’s notification settings.

Read more

 
advertisement

    Latest Analysis & Insight Videos in Mobile

Q&A: Mikko Hyppönen, chief research officer, F-Secure

Play Q&A: Mikko Hyppönen, chief research officer, F-Secure   Play

We ask one of the leading experts on cyber crime for an assessment of the recent spate of cyber attacks and the growing threats to companies...

 
Sponsored Links
Advertisement