By Andrew Miller in Reader
Posted in Linux on September 8, 2008 at 11:39 am
What a great way to start my week, but with a rant about a BBC article on Linux. I will be the first to admit that Linux isn’t quite ready for consumer consumption - but it’s certainly very close. If Mr Parkinson wanted to actually give Linux a go, he should have researched a little more - like I don’t know, asking any of the thousands of Linux users out there who would have given him some wonderful advice and probably filled the holes in his article. The first thing they wouldn’t have recommended is to try replacing the stock distribution on an EeePC.
Trying GNU/Linux is made very hard because it is such an organic product - not only are there thousands of distributions, but there are new releases of each every 6 months or so. Trying Windows is easy, you can move from machine to machine and find everything exactly the same, and there are only a finite number of versions available. So when people keep harping on about the EeePC running Linux, they assume that just like Windows, everyone that uses Linux uses what the EeePC uses. “What? So our server admin uses THIS? Hmm - I thought Mac’s were simple.”
As far as I’m concerned - the EeePC doesn’t run Linux. It certainly doesn’t run Xandros as the article suggest. It may have been based on Xandros, but it is not a complete operating system - it is stripped down and designed specifically for the EeePC with its own interface, just like the operating system on your phone is designed for your phone. It is not designed to be expanded, except by the Asus specific update tool. Complaining that you had to open a terminal to do something the device is not designed for is misleading to the public. For the majority of situations now, you do not need to open a terminal in a complete Linux OS.
The article continues, with his biggest complaint that he can’t synchronise with his iPod. Ok - so that much is true, it doesn’t. But this is the fault of Apple, who feel they have to control everything with their DRM and force people to use their music software. Why do you think very few Linux users have an iPod? There is no freedom with your music if you own an Apple music device. That’s why I still buy CDs and rip them myself, so I’m in control. The writer then suggests that we never see iTunes on Linux because Apple don’t follow the same “hippy mentality” of open source. Software does not have to be open source to be available on Linux - it can be a closed binary, just like the nVidia graphics card drivers. Apple just don’t want to. Of all people to understand what it is like to have a small control of the OS market - it’s Apple. And considering the Unix origins of Mac OS, would it really be that hard to port it?
His piece reads like he’s giving Linux a thorough test. If this was his intention, then using the EeePC was a big mistake. However, the fact the WiFi didn’t work in Ubuntu? Very valid and annoying, which is why I still recommend looking up Linux compatibility before making the jump. I guess if this chap had written this anywhere else, I could forgive elements of it. But having pride of place on the BBC website, it is very damaging to Linux’s reputation and misleading to the public. It’s not a review, or look at Linux - it’s a blog of one man’s struggle to make a device (yes, the EeePC is a device) do something it shouldn’t. I’m sure if they had enabled comments on the piece - there would be some angry comments there at the moment. Sigh.
Rated: 66.67% (9 votes)
Loading ...Comment by pcole - September 8, 2008 on 6:07 pm
BBC is MS media. Most ANALysts there are MS trolls.
Comment by John Bailey - September 9, 2008 on 1:53 am
Pretty standard “I tried Linux and it wasn’t Windows”.. Nothing new.
Comment by Michael - September 9, 2008 on 4:44 am
Actually, on Ubuntu there are a few wifi gremlins, but if I restart networking after booting up it usually gets a connection.
Comment by alan - September 9, 2008 on 5:22 am
It’s funny, isn’t it… you hear people say all the time “I don’t care about source code, I just want it to work”. Yet 9 times out of ten, if you look at the standard “not working” gripes, it eventually boils down to proprietary code somewhere along the line: hardware not working, software not available, peripheral drivers, etc.
Comment by ASD - September 9, 2008 on 1:18 pm
Too bad BBC couldn’t give you the opportunity to have this on their website to counter that article…it seems that almost all reviews of someone new trying linux is on some old machine or using outdated hardware on purpose to complain that it doesn’t work…I have been using Mandriva Linux and haven’t had any complaints…it is just another person using a hammer to a screw and complaining that it doesn’t work instead of using a screwdriver.
Comment by Frihet - September 9, 2008 on 1:43 pm
I am thinking BBC simply do not want to mess with FOSS. You’ll get nothing but lip service from them.
I have put Mandriva 2008 on my EeePC to be rid of the MS/Xandros OS. It works nicely out of the box, wireless included.
Comment by Nick - September 10, 2008 on 7:12 pm
I agree with your rant. I thought the article was dreadful. It is becoming clear that the only technology that the BBC wish to comment on is American monopoly. I also looked for a way to counter this fools ramblings, but as usual, they know when they are about to get volume responses.
Comment by anonymous - September 23, 2008 on 12:02 am
linux does have support for the apple ipod, at least some versions with gtkpod. Of course this user, as you said, didn’t have access to a package manager which would allow for the easy installation of gtkpod. the program allows for the easy mounting and modification of the ipod.
Trackback by - February 9, 2012 on 6:32 am
sopac water polo…
[…]making it 13 victories from 13 races – said of her decision[…]…
Make a comment
Tag cloud
Most commented posts
- Linux Has Been Tick Boxed
30 comments
- Fixing The Unbroken
- BBC in covering technology badly shocker.
- Webcams on Linux a hit
- Ubuntu deadlines causes dead cards.
- Linux netbooks returned more than Windows
- Android on Netbooks - Not Quite Ready
- GNU? Isn't that some kind of monkey?
- Nobody at IBM is using Vista
- Be Social
Highest Rated Blog Posts
- Linux netbooks returned more than Windows (100%)
- Flash 10 on Linux Launches in Unison (100%)
- Android Released to the Wild (100%)
- Creative Releases X-Fi Drives as Open Source (100%)
- Is that a projector in your pocket, or... (100%)
- Windows Package Managment? (100%)
- SMTP Relay for Google Apps Users (100%)
- Fixing The Unbroken (100%)
- GNU? Isn't that some kind of monkey? (95%)
- Ubuntu deadlines causes dead cards. (90%)
