ADSL and why I am happy a neighbor is moving.
Posted in ADSL, Networking on February 4, 2008 at 9:39 am
I’ve had ADSL since around 2003 - initially with a 512K service, then 2Mbit, then MAX upon release, all via Andrews and Arnold (who incidentially provide a fine service or I would have moved ages ago).
Anyhow, this post is about my experience over the past few years since I moved into my new build house in
Comment by Nick Palmer - February 5, 2008 on 9:13 am
That’s domestic ADSL for you; however A&A were tarting it up, what they were selling you was BT’s domestic ADSL Max service, and that’s contended at up to 50:1 at the local exchange. Max sucks. Badly. Frankly Max is one reason I’m glad I’m still on cable. I manage a fair few business ADSL connections at work, and the quality of the service since BT began shifting people over (with no consultation or permission) from fixed 2Mbit to “Up to 8Mbit” Max has been abysmal. Connections dropping, synch failures, endless router restarts… Yes, you probably WILL see your speeds drop, and when you complain they’ll tell you “but we advertised UP TO 8Mbit…”.
Comment by Tim Regester - February 5, 2008 on 10:56 am
This oddly makes sense and here is my suggestion as to how.
Your ADSL connection is provided over copper wires, the actual pairs of copper are uniquely allocated to your number so that there is a unique pair from the exchange to the street cabinet, a unique pair from the street cabinet to the telephone pole and possibly but not always, a unique pair from the telephone pole to the building of your home.
In almost all cases the pair entering your house and terminating either at a junction box or a master Line Jack Unit are alone, i.e they are not colocated next to other copper pairs. But from the exchange almost to your house the pair is in a multicore cable carrying up to hundreds of pairs.
This is the reason for your speed drop. One pair will radiate signal electronically to surrounding pairs, this can easily be picked up by those pairs as noise, increase the noise and lower the Signal to Noise Ratio. It is called crosstalk and a BT engineer confirmed to me it is an increasing issue.
Voice over the pair creates far less noise than an DSL signal so the more DSL users in a shared multicore, the more noise and the worse the available speed.
Visit your router they will all quote SNR or SNR Margin, make a note of this figure as well as, if quoted the loop attenuation figure, (the level of the signal on the line or gain).
Add a new neighbour using ADSL and these figures will change and your link speed will probably fall.
In a business context BT will, if you can prove these figures are causing too many HEC errors (ATM errors caused by dodgy signals), change over the pair in the shared section until you get a better SNR and better connection, but my experience is that they will only do this if it really marginal and drops out. Finding the proof of this is really hard, (it took me 3 weeks and I am trained in ATM, have Eclipse as an ISP, who were excellent as always, and finally fixed it with an old hand BT Outreach engineer.
Trackback by - February 9, 2012 on 7:54 am
greenpeace 2012 calendar standing up for the earth…
[…]his family and hundreds of thousands of global supporters, campaigners and celebrities wait patiently […]…
Make a comment
Archives
- July 2009
- June 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- February 2008
- January 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
- August 2007
- April 2007
- March 2007
- February 2007
- January 2007
- October 2006
- September 2006
- August 2006
Most commented posts
Highest Rated Blog Posts
- Debian & APT - Why I love it (100%)
- PicardTagger - most useful mp3 tool ever? (100%)
- Nokia Comes with Music - doomed to fail? (100%)
- The death of the British High Street (100%)
- Fighting Spam with Spamassassin (100%)
- iPhone 2.1 Upgrade - Genius! (100%)
- ADSL and why I am happy a neighbor is moving. (80%)
- Homebuilt NAS - one week on (80%)
- Second Life - a big waste of time? (75%)
- Day 4 of me.com/iPhone, my mini-review (73.4%)


