Mad Murdoch cuts off news nose to spite face
By Davey Winder in Editorial
Posted in Business, Blog, Internet, e-commerce on
Online news sites rely heavily on incoming traffic from search engines and aggregator sites to attract visitors, so it might seem a little odd that Rupert Murdoch (a mogul in denial) would decide that these are bad for business. Yet that is exactly what appears to have happened in the case of Times Online which has banned leading UK news aggregator service NewsNow from linking to any content it publishes.
The blocking itself would appear to be a simple robots.txt protocol implementation, but the reasoning behind the action is a little more complex. After all, it is not as if NewsNow is scraping content or stealing stories to publish as its own for profit. All NewsNow does, in this case, is grab the headline of the story and link to it. Those links are then presented to anyone, for free, who visits the NewsNow site.
For one thing, such linking is a recognised and effective way to drive traffic to the publishing sites. here at IT Pro our stories, including this one, get linked to by NewsNow and if they are popular enough to get featured in the top ten section, for example, the additional traffic driven in this direction can be quite substantial. To prevent this linking would be the equivalent of cutting off your nose to spite your face.
I’m also rather concerned that to prevent such linking is actually eroding a rather important freedom that, as a journalist, I do not want to see damaged in any way: the freedom to quote sources in stories, to link to those sources in stories and to comment upon the views of others reporting the news. This action by Murdoch smells bad to me, it stinks of an attempt to further restrict the rights of those reporting the news. Of course, the fact that Times Online journalists quote other stories, and link to them, cannot have escaped the irony detectors of everyone outside of the News International family.
According to a statement from NewsNow Managing Director Struan Bartlett, two million visitors to the NewsNow site each month will now no longer find headlines and links to Times Online content in their news search results. “It is lamentable that News International has chosen to request we stop linking to their content and providing in-bound traffic and potential subscribers to the Times Online and right now it looks as though NewsNow has been singled out” Bartlett says, adding “we note that no other major search engine has been blocked by NI in this manner. NewsNow is not fundamentally different to other news search engines that are part of the Internet infrastructure, such as Google News and Yahoo. Why block us and not them?”
Good question, and one can only assume it is in order to test the waters on a relative small fry before tackling the big fish which have some seriously heavyweight legal resources to draw upon. NewsNow had already pulled links to newspaper websites which were covered by the Newspaper Licensing Agency from its subscription based service last month, after a change in policy required permissions to be sought and fees paid for circulating such links. That policy change has been, Bartlett says, to the Copyright Tribunal.
Oddly, News International was not involved in the NLA scheme but it has seemingly taken a similar stance albeit through this selective blocking process. As Bartlett concludes “the question remains whether News International, in arbitrarily blocking individual search engines, is trying to use its muscle to gain unreasonable control over the public’s freedom to choose the way they access information and news online”.
I’d be keen to hear what IT Pro readers think of this move, and in the meantime for more information you can visit the Right2Link campaign.
Rated: 75% (4 votes)
Loading ...Comment by Richard Shearwood - January 9, 2010 on 12:06 pm
Well if I don’t see the headlines in Google News I’m not going to bookmark the site and check it on the offchance. My day is short enough without that sort of retro nonsense. I suppose it’s an attempt to recreate the days when you picked your newspaper for delivery and that was that but on the internet can that EVER work? And do these organisations really want to encourage Google to acquire it’s own news agency?
Comment by anonymous ish - January 9, 2010 on 12:30 pm
Perhaps its time to black hole the email for all of Murdock’s companies for a few days as a demonstration of what happens when chunks of the net become more difficult to access?
Pingback by - January 9, 2010 on 12:49 pm
[…] IT PRO: Blogs: Davey Winder: Murdoch cuts off news nose to spite face www.itpro.co.uk/blogs/daveyw/2010/01/09/ – view page – cached , Online news sites rely heavily on incoming traffic from search engines and aggregator sites to attract visitors, so it might seem a little odd that Rupert […]
Trackback by - February 9, 2012 on 5:22 am
greenpeace flag…
[…]against Lennox and his household is now out of the hands of Belfast Town Council […]…
Trackback by - February 9, 2012 on 7:30 am
sopac water polo…
[…]making it 13 victories from 13 races – said of her decision[…]…
Comment by JoannaDorsey23 - February 19, 2012 on 11:38 am
I guess that to receive the loans from banks you must have a good reason. But, one time I’ve got a bank loan, just because I was willing to buy a house.
Make a comment
Tag cloud
Archives
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- February 2008
- January 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
- August 2007
- July 2007
- June 2007
- May 2007
- April 2007
- March 2007
- February 2007
- January 2007
- December 2006
- November 2006
- October 2006
- September 2006
- August 2006
Most commented posts
- 80 percent of viruses love Windows 7
165 comments
- Has Microsoft gone mental?
- Has the US Army declared war on Windows 7?
- Cuil frozen out: market share drops to next to nothing
- Xbox 360 FAIL
- The 24GB RAM Desktop is born
- Use old version of Windows instead of Linux, says teacher
- Microsoft reveals time-based licensing model
- How Marblecake Hacked Time
- Nexus Two - The Next Generation
Highest Rated Blog Posts
- Why ecommerce fails (100%)
- Google Chrome stands alone at PWN2OWN (100%)
- Betting on Hubdub technology (100%)
- Has Google gone insane as GMail goes back to beta? (100%)
- Chinese whispers as government implicated in UK hack attacks (100%)
- Crimeware toolkit targets 10,000 trusted sites (100%)
- Black Hat risk to migrating VMs (100%)
- Tough on cyber crime, tough on the causes of cyber crime (100%)
- Firefox 3, Beta 4, Enhancements 900, Tested 5 (100%)
- Has the US Army declared war on Windows 7? (100%)
