Skip to navigation
   
Mark Tennent's Blog
Suggestions requested for router replacement

By Mark Tennent in Reader

Posted in Broadband, Internet on June 25, 2009 at 10:42 am

Permalink | Author Profile

According to behavioural scientists, it takes three days for people to settle down after a major event. As we have just returned from beautiful Brittany, three days is a gross under estimation, it takes us about 6 months or until the next holiday.

What a beautiful part of the world is Brittany, with long, white sandy beaches and rocky coves rivalling the best in the world. The English Channel turns deep blue and everywhere are the fruits of the sea with oysters and shellfish so fresh and cheap you just have to gorge yourself. (Didn’t notice any ‘other’ benefits of eating oysters.)

What do we come back to? More of the same sums it up. Our new Netgear router, a DGN2000 to replace the brand new Netgear DG834G we bought a few weeks ago, is doing the same as the last one, the wireless networks become hit and miss. This time we have found the problem if not the solution. Often we open our laptops and find the networks are there but won’t let us on unless we reboot the router, and then only sometimes.

The router can run up to 4 separate wireless networks at one time. We have to run two of them because of recent changes in wifi data encryption so that our old iBook, which cannot connect using WPA2-PSK, has its own WEP network. Meanwhile our newer MacBook gets up to N speeds and uses WPA2-PSK.

Reading the on-screen messages and using sniffers, the networks lose their ‘identity’, their names vanish leaving a blank where the broadcast name should be. Other times, the WPA2 networks starts demanding a WEP password.

The DGN834G just wasn’t up to managing a network with four or more computers, even two were pushing its capabilities. If one Mac was sending or receiving via FTP, it hogged the whole bandwidth no matter what we did to the router’s QoS settings. Similarly with transferring files across the network. Our Linksys WAG54GS isn’t compatible with BT’s C21 MSLAMs at our local exchange and our DLink 604+ is ADSL1/802.11b slow. Both routers, on the other hand, have excellent wireless routers that gave zero difficulties for years.

All suggestions for a replacement router requested.

12345
Rated: 60% (2 votes)
Loading ... Loading ...

Previous Post | Next Post

 
 
Comments

Comment by Fotis - July 4, 2009 on 4:20 pm

If you don’t need “N” capabilities and you got no DSLAM compatibility issues I would recommend the good ‘old’ Linksys WRT54GL (the L for Linux). Great solid router and lots of Open source alternative firmwares for special needs.

Comment by Mark Tennent - July 4, 2009 on 8:54 pm

Thanks for the suggestion. I’ll check out whether it’s compatible but I think BT are saying there are problems with many Linksys routers and the 21CN kit (MSANS?).

Make a comment

* required

* required

We stop spam using reCaptcha.
Type the words below and click Submit Comment.

   
Tag cloud

Xendai Apple iPhone 32- or 64- bit Kernel Startup Mode Selector EDS remote control Apple Newton 1Password Government Entanet proxy server manager BBC iPlayer EST Fetch broadband speed Audio Books for Free iChat font manager Quark FontAgent Pro atvFlash Muscadet Time zones 21CN Apple TV QuarkXPress CalcService Apple Cube Steve Jobs Zune 'Library of Congress' 'digital images' 'Image Engineering' 'Matthew Brady' photography 'Samuel Morse' SoundSource iPhone Cocoa iTunes Dell Service menu PDF TomTom CS Suite Rick Stein Elgato Carbonized MacPro Mac Pro Linksys iPad Siemens Many Tricks software CoPilot Windows 7 Media Player phpBB Vidahost MacBook Air CyTV Lucidcake 'Andreas Junghans' Mac OS X Services wifi iPlayer Downloader Cheltenham and Gloucester Service Scrubber iPlayer Phil Schiller Time Capsule Garmin Apple iMac Telefonica encryption ADSL entertainment industry Suitcase Fusion TNT IBM spy satellite images Jamie Oliver SpeedMail GMT Back to My Mac Lewis Hamilton Bacchus iPod SimplyRAR France Telecom 18185.co.uk Lotus Notes uplink vBulletin BT anarchie Logmein for the iPhone PC Tools iAntiVirus Mike Markkola Panic Inc Adobe compression Insider Software App Store Gil Amelio FileMaker WordPress EyeTV3 Elgato CYTV Andreas Junghans Bonjour Netgear Logmein O2 CoPilot Live Logmein Ignition Adobe PageMill British Telecom Western Digital MyBook Pro CRB checks Orange Broadband Max unilities Ron Wayne onOne Software iPad Mini Motorola Freehand Kira Knightley OpenCL CAPTCHA softwear Suitcase Fusion 2 AppleTV Andrew Tomazos veronica Mosaic Acrobat Gennaro Contaldo Growl Mighty Mouse MacWorld magazine BST Genuine Fractals gopher Anarchy Hamlet Mac OS X Seagate Barracudas Kate Beckinsale Snow Leopard Mac OS X 10.6 Moondrop to Gascony Public Enemies Civinfo Spamhaus Steve Linford Spam CAN-SPAM Nano French Resistance Lawrence Dudley Port Map MacBook Coding Monkeys ClamXav SETI Aquiss WordService Mike Spindler Leopard Apple Mac Mini Safari-tweaks Windows XP BT Central Pipes Fatboy iPod Gestapo Smart Guides Parexcel satnav The 88 Cisco pontum Q2ID insurance cellphone Safari 4 Honfleur Napster HSBC Simon Pinkerton Claris HomePage Gauloise Adobe Flash 'Flash Cookies' Macromedia LaserWriter Apple Coffee break French Optiplex Joan of Arc FTP Apple Portable portforward Macromedia Ofcom MacWorld Expo Linotype FontExplorer Pro Apple Macintosh Helen Mirren Markzware Firewire SuperDuper web browsers paperless bills Bellhop Moho Books Phototshop 20CN TV and Video FontDoctor BT Connect Hat Full of Sky Linotype FontExplorer Call of Duty Transmit Andrew Potts Extensis MarkWahlberg Dr Who Dell Studio Hybrid Rogue Amoeba Maggie Thatcher Tobias Meyerhoff HP EyeTV ADSL2+ FourTrack Michael Mann Lotus Honda Civic pxl SmartScale 1802 Hotpoint broadband Jim Kidwell Jonathan Ives
Advertisement
Advertisement