Skip to navigation
   
Simon Bisson & Mary Branscombe's Blog

Is Apple rushing Snow Leopard out ahead of Windows 7?

By Simon Bisson & Mary Branscombe in Editorial

Posted in Windows 7, operating systems, Applications, Microsoft, Apple on September 1, 2009 at 12:26 pm

Permalink | Author Profile

Windows 7 is done, but the massive Microsoft machinery is grinding slowly through the process of localising it into multiple languages, burning discs, printing, stuffing and shipping boxes and getting the PC manufacturers on the starting line. Snow Leopard is done and it went on sale on Friday. Does that mean Apple is more nimble - or just in more of a hurry?

Since Snow Leopard went on sale there’s been a flurry of posts and questions - about application compatibility. We knew Snow Leopard itself wouldn’t run on PowerPC Macs because they don’t have the Intel chips that the new features rely on, but unlike Microsoft’s massive app testing and beta program Apple hadn’t been pushing out details about application compatibility. Running 32-bit apps on a 64-bit system often causes problems. Apple was prepared for this; the reviewer’s guide says “During installation, Snow Leopard checks your applications for compatibility, and sets aside any incompatible applications that are known to create instability in Snow Leopard” and this page on the Apple support site http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3258 lists a handful of apps that are known to have problems. Most of them are the usual suspects; low-level storage and security software that has to be updated with any operating system release. But a wireless broadband card, or Adobe Director MX 2004? That’s down to a large number of API changes, designed to remove old bugs - but as Microsoft has often found, one developer’s bug is another developer’s feature and fixing it can break an app.

There was quite the snowstorm of discussion at John Nack’s blog about Adobe products and Snow Leopard. http://blogs.adobe.com/jnack/snow_leopard/ The official policy; CS4 is supported on Mac OS X 10.6, although Version Cue doesn’t work, CS3 isn’t supported. The unofficial line; CS3 “works fine” “to the best of our knowledge”; cue discussion about how long you should support old software on a new platform and whether you should delay creating the Cocoa version of Photoshop to go back and do the testing. But beyond the question of what resources Adobe could or should devote to supporting an OS update when it’s company policy not to put out updates to versions of software it no longer sells, is the question of how much time Apple has spent on testing third-party apps - and how much it could be telling users about potential compatibility issues. Apple certainly works very closely with the Photoshop team and would know about any problems they found (”If we found issues, we worked directly with Apple to get them fixed,” blogged Photoshop quality assurance manager David Howe) but there’s nothing about Version Cue on the support pages.

For Windows 7, Microsoft worked with 45,000 hardware and software developers, from IT departments inside businesses to one-man-bands to the big software and hardware names. There’s a long list of just a proportion of the devices tested at http://blogs.msdn.com/e7/archive/2009/01/10/primer-on-device-support-and-testing-for-windows-7.aspx and when you can actually buy Windows 7, the Windows Upgrade Advisor will be out of beta (http://www.microsoft.com/downloads/details.aspx?displaylang=en&FamilyID=1b544e90-7659-4bd9-9e51-2497c146af15) - this checks the hardware and software you have installed -  the Vista Compatibility Center http://www.microsoft.com/windows/compatibility/ will turn into the Windows 7 Compatibility Center where you can look up that Photoshop Album needs a free upgrade to v3.2 and Corel makes you pay to upgrade to Paint Shop Pro X2. We’re still impressed by the range of hardware and software Windows 7 supports; at the end of last week our elderly Elonex Media Center PC picked up a new driver for the Hauppauge TV card that hadn’t worked for years and suddenly offered up 98 Freeview TV and radio channels.

Apple doesn’t give Mac users this level of detail (there’s a list of supported printers and scanners at http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3669 but nothing official for software), so they’re gathering it informally; check http://snowleopard.wikidot.com/ for a long list of apps that do and don’t have problems.

It’s unlikely that any of these application compatibility problems mean that Snow Leopard wasn’t ready to ship. But perhaps Apple isn’t able to test as widely as Microsoft does or perhaps it was so keen to get Snow Leopard on sale to deflate some of the Windows 7 momentum that it didn’t take the time to document the issues. Or is it the back to school market that Apple is chasing, now rather dominated by netbooks (which DisplaySearch now puts at 22% of all personal computers sold)? 
-Mary

12345
Rated: 40% (1 votes)
Loading ... Loading ...

Previous Post | Next Post

 
 
Comments

Comment by Roger Holloway - September 1, 2009 on 1:07 pm

I’ve given Snow Leopard a good run and it does exactly what it says on the box. Smooth as silk. It is also V.fast with Apple software, switching on and off. I look forward to Adobe upgrading to 64 bit!

I gave up on Microsoft long ago, far too clunky and glitchy!

Roger

Comment by william - September 1, 2009 on 5:15 pm

I have loaded Snow Leopard on 2 computers and have run into the same problem on each: I cannot click on a “group” in the email address book and have it put the full group in the address… it only puts in the first name. I have spoken to Apple Tech Support and have made them aware of this issue.

Comment by Steve Jobs - September 1, 2009 on 6:26 pm

Nice try in trying to bring Snow Leopard down. You can talk about windows being more thorough, but they still don’t have a better OS than Snow leopard.

Trackback by Denis Sterkenburg - February 9, 2012 on 8:37 am

will smith and jada divorce reason…

[…]council employees at Lennox’s ultimate charm hearing back again in September. […]…

Make a comment

* required

* required

We stop spam using reCaptcha.
Type the words below and click Submit Comment.

   
Tag cloud

virtualisation g-2 apps deperimeterization uninstall Google co-processor Xobni thin client business model i-mate CardSpace voice recognition interoperability data tariff security theatre Tombstone Objects disk Tim Berners-Lee MAX RBL claims windows 7 analytics mobile Linux mobile numbers VSSAdmin development history WPF SSD instant messaging Vista IT value geek tourism Smartbook futura RIM Mercury wildfire cam old software NVIDIA gabriola g-1 geocaching regulation Skyfire management M&A consolidation Acrobat Pro cold fusion lockdown biometrics OFCOM multiple monitors radeon rtm tele atlas anti-virus cellcrypt WinHEC images exabytes green IT context exchange ikea Asus disaster recovery DOS bugs Corsair drivers Large Hadron Collider 64-bit timezones service oriented enterprise mobility appstore developer regulations accessories web 2.0 expo Windows Mobile cloud service google online applications TouchSmart encryption 965 international roaming Netscape keyboard parallel computing quiz verdana mms 2009 goview camera CIO pre-boot Adobe SMB 2 system center infrastructure Jeff Hawkins mobile broadband rich client Clear RX fire power Trampoline Embarcadero BBC ports IBM xT9 MIX08 mash-up EMC advertising TSA netbook demo09 Greasemoneky application compatibility community Tom Hogan NexT trends web Visual Studio QWERTY Internet pgp icons screencam adfs Trend Micro IO HSPA Web 2.0 distributed computing CTO server pixetell amherst Crossfader DOSBox magic sun Opera applications cracking html social networking Dell visualisation search IIW2008b anti-patterns competition bbc iplayer navteq malware traffic emulator Toshiba Portege R500 Previous Versions Chrome ATI p2v virtual desktop OEM benchmark macbook business IT policy social engineering demo designer venture capital Windows Live d2c public cloud NGSCB licensing MIX yahoo HMT wave cables monitor storage bandwidth fault IDF flash drive high performance computing SKU Netscan data centre transformation email docking station cisco IT transformation processors fingerprint RAZR nvision08 O'Reilly Mini-Note legislation WEI navigation twitter identity metasystem cloud computing natural interface HSDPA london Windows Server workflow tennis Gears codec turing iPass geotagging Hp 2710p web2expo Dopplr etech Enterprise 2.0 SapphireSteel security hibernation netiquette GPS Windows Server 2008 direct access future in review secure october gamer flex forensics DisplayLink MacBook Air Barracuda Salesforce identitity pen computing Bill Cheswick hyper-v Numenta ubuntu ucsd ProCurve hard drive enterprise architecture productivity Lenovo Volume Shadow Copy Moonlight Tablet Kiosk data loss prevention networks design media MING AIR Hugh Thompson TechEd 2008 mythbusters routing Secunia virus identity theft Itanium support isps Apple fibre streaming media Active Directory Windows 7 vs Windows Vista office 2010 ontier wubi video hierarchical temporal memory moblin Istanbul Gartner user interface LiveID Sony Google Sets mainframe Bill Gates DSL Ask.com patch Tuesday setup smartphone hacking task bar information cards optical interconnects ultraportable system management Ray Ozzie enterprise bug business technology optimisation AMD bombe CUDA Safari education Live Mesh SP1 ClipMate HP phone management T-Mobile people cloud HTC business intelligence Mono Tablet PC windows server 2008 r2 bletchley park griffin anti-trust wireless USB privacy Beacon fonts android semiotics ribbon christmas Linux beta city gameboard hold music Girl Geek Dinners Frauenhofer project macro Delphi rc active digitiser hdmi information rights management troubleshooting bea software BlackBerry phone settings insert SIM spam fighting bolt ANR telecoms Nokia catalyst fingerprint scanner UMPC Tripit netbooks Magny-Cours offload iPhone lawsuit IT automation mobile network ADFS 2.0 RSS search meaning green printing it pro Express Gate dual boot mysql collaboration remove back business technology automation WWW microsoft security essentials teched user experience conference MWC control panel acquisitions market share hp microsoft research culture Trolltech machine learning winhec2008 clean install office politics augmented reality congestion charge CES ballmerbot deborah adler Internet Explorer 8 upgrade RIA case merger private cloud LHC BT dual display thermo wifi target server sprawl Palm 2.0 OQO Microsoft calit2 Pal electricity price appzero beta test Seagate Loki gaming wes Reqall desktop. PC whitelist evernote patent Bing ruggedized BitLocker CPU hardware MacWorld 2008 Silverlight Google Spreadsheets conferences network greenplum AskEraser logitech vmware microsoft research Google IO Facebook Mozilla geneva BES installation ipv6 Wimbledon Firefox aws mobile working performance Xen police display O2 safend mobile data tariffs dvi Verbatim mobile ofcom network todo list eu isp disk space tablet open ipsec oracle data centre cosmic rays 2009 downturn transcoding MRDA robot ec2 connectivity annotation Eee PC installer media center EEE Palladium accelerator CERN .NET FUD Mark Hurd training mscape migration Protected View innovation vulnerabilities power supply voice security paradox politics national museum of computing SBS maps switch Credentica Motorola OpenID battery life Ruby On Rails amazon Intel Jeff Jones Treo Pro information T9 DLP webkit no signal usb Opteron Vodafone RSA 2008 power saving IM power cuts credit crunch Internet Explorer Nuance lost server utilities GPL firewall AuthenTec business continuity moscow citrix toshiba utility outlook office HTML 5 relocation Opsware GPU database Qualcomm flash NAS terabytes browser data loss Location screen Quest backhaul data Wyse laptop Java Fire Eagle how do I get the back off? spam Ruby windows 3G atom colossus open source legacy mapping
Advertisement
Advertisement