Microsoft slams Google digital book settlement

Microsoft has called the settlement an 'unprecedented misuse of the judicial system'.

digital books

Microsoft has again gone head-to-head with Google, calling the web giant's digital book settlement "an unprecedented misuse of the judicial system".

This week, the deadline passed to file an opinion on the US settlement, leaving the judge to decided whether or not to approve a $125 million deal allowing Google to create a massive registry of digitised books.

Litigation began back in 2005, when American publishers and authors objected to Google's digitisation of books for its online search engine without permission. Under the settlement, Google will pay $125 million to a new digital books registry, which would include millions of "orphan" works - those still protected under copyright but whose copyright holders are unknown or untraceable.

The settlement also allots 70 per cent of any revenue generated from advertisements or digital book sales for authors and publishers.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement - Article continues below

If approved, Microsoft argued, the settlement will grant Google a monopoly on digital books.

"A class action settlement is the wrong mechanism, this court is the wrong venue, and monopolization is the wrong means to carry out the worthy goal of digitizing and increasing the accessibility of books," Microsoft's lawyers wrote in a filing to the US District Court of New York.

Microsoft added that the deal would harm its business. "Microsoft was and remains interested in search technology to improve access to digital books, an interest that would be substantially harmed by approval of the proposed settlement," the filing said.

Microsoft claimed that Google's "closed-door" negotiations undermined the rights of authors.

"The class representatives bargained away millions of absent class members' incontestable rights to prevent the reproduction, distribution, public display, public performance and other uses of their copyrighted books rights that are not remotely in dispute in this case," the company said.

Last week Amazon filed a similar complaint, arguing the book deal was "anti-competitive" and "the stuff of antitrust nightmares."

Advertisement - Article continues below

In August, the two technology heavyweights, joined by Yahoo, joined the Open Book Alliance, a coalition that opposes Google's book deal.

Google has said that the deal will actually benefit authors by creating new forms of revenue.

"The new registry should help reduce the number of in-copyright works whose owners cannot be identified or found because authors will have a concrete economic incentive to come forward, claim their works and then earn money," Daniel Clancy, Google engineering director, wrote in a blog post.

"For books that are in-print, the agreement would offer new distribution opportunities to copyright holders in the United States."

The deal is currently being discussed by the European Commission.

Featured Resources

How inkjet can transform your business

Get more out of your business by investing in the right printing technology

Download now

Journey to a modern workplace with Office 365: which tools and when?

A guide to how Office 365 builds a modern workplace

Download now

Modernise and transform your sales organisation

Learn how a modernised sales process can drive your business

Download now

Your guide to managing cloud transformation risk

Realise the benefits. Mitigate the risks

Download now



Google Nest Wifi review: A solid improvement, but not for long

14 Feb 2020
unified communications (UC)

Google developing all in one messaging app for business

29 Jan 2020
cloud computing

Google adds partners to real-time translation tools

8 Jan 2020

The IT Pro Products of the Year 2019: All the year’s best hardware

24 Dec 2019

Most Popular

cloud computing

Google Cloud snaps up multi-cloud analytics platform for $2.6bn

13 Feb 2020

How to use Chromecast without Wi-Fi

5 Feb 2020
Microsoft Azure

Microsoft Azure is a testament to Satya Nadella’s strategic nouse

14 Feb 2020
operating systems

How to fix a stuck Windows 10 update

12 Feb 2020