Private browsing ‘not so private’
Private browsing does not offer complete protection from snoopers as data is leaked in various ways, a report has claimed.
Private browsing does not offer complete security from determined attackers and more needs to be done to offer stronger protection, a report has suggested.
Looking at Safari, Firefox, Google Chrome and Internet Explorer, researchers from Stanford and Carnegie Mellon University found each browser leaked user data in differing ways during or after private sessions.
One problem is operating systems often store certain DNS data. An attacker with control over a user's system can look at the DNS cache post-browsing and learn if and when the user visited a specific website, the researchers explained.
"Thus, to properly implement private browsing, the browser will need to ensure that all DNS queries while in private mode do not affect the system's DNS cache," the report said.
"None of the mainstream browsers currently address this issue."
One experiment showed how URLs of visited websites had been stored on the computer's swap file, despite privacy being on, along with links in those pages and sometimes even text from a site.
"A full implementation of private browsing will need to prevent browser memory pages from being swapped out," the report read, again noting none of the mainstream browsers do this.
Researchers also showed how many popular browser extensions undermined the security of private browsing.
"Browser add-ons pose a privacy risk to private browsing because they can persist state to disk about a user's behavior in private mode," the report claimed.
"The developers of these add-ons may not have considered private browsing mode while designing their software, and their source code is not subject to the same rigorous scrutiny that browsers are subjected to."
The study paper, due to be delivered at the Usenix security conference next week, also found private browsing was used more frequently in services which used "subtle private browsing indicators."
"Safari and Firefox have subtle indicators and enforce a single mode across all windows; they had the highest rate of private browsing use."
Unsurprisingly, the report showed how private settings were used more often when searching porn sites than when looking for surprise gifts.
How virtual desktop infrastructure enables digital transformation
Challenges and benefits of VDIFree download
The Okta digital trust index
Exploring the human edge of trustFree download
Optimising workload placement in your hybrid cloud
Deliver increased IT agility with the cloudFree Download
Modernise endpoint protection and leave your legacy challenges behind
The risk of keeping your legacy endpoint security toolsDownload now