Celestix MSA 3200i review

Microsoft has replaced its venerable ISA Server with Forefront TMG 2010 and Celestix delivers it as a complete plug-and-go security appliance. Read this exclusive review of the MSA 3200i to see if it is a more sensible alternative to buying and installing TMG yourself.

The TMG reporting interface sees a modest redesign and the latest SP1 update brings in user activity reports so you can see what individuals have been up to and those that have used the rule override option. The reports can be very detailed and can be used to view traffic patterns, cache, protocol and application usage plus security alerts.

Basic real time monitoring is provided but we found it really annoying that no report on the current activity could be raised until the following day. TMG still uses the Dailysum utility from ISA Server which can only query the reporting database once a day.

Email security can begin once you've typed your Exchange servers and mail domains in to TMG and wizards are provided to create basic policies. This component snaps neatly into the TMG console and assigns SCL (spam confidence level) scores to suspect email.

Based on their SCL score, spam messages can be deleted, rejected or quarantined but no options are provided for tagging subjects and letting them through. TMG provides tough anti-virus measures as it uses scanning engines from Kaspersky, Authentium, Norman, VirusBuster and Microsoft.

Forefront TMG 2010 is a vast improvement over ISA Server as it provides a wealth of new features including web filtering, anti-malware, anti-virus and HTTPS inspection. Existing users of ISA Server would do well to upgrade but the change to a 64-bit operating system means they must do a clean install and migrate their settings to TMG.

The Celestix MSA 3200i looks a much more sensible choice as it has everything preinstalled and ready to run. It's also unlikely you'd save much cash by doing it yourself as you'll need to factor in TMG licensing costs plus the dedicated server hardware and underlying Server 2008 64-bit OS and, of course, your valuable time.

Verdict

It makes sense for existing users of ISA Server to move up to Forefront TMG 2010 as it has a wealth of new security measures. Our main issues are that TMG’s optional messaging security only supports Exchange and the separately licensed web filtering and anti-virus features will push the price up. Even so, the MSA 3200i takes all the hard work out of deploying TMG and will probably work out better value than trying to do it all yourself.

Chassis: 1U rack Processor: Intel Core 2 Duo Memory: 4GB DDR2 RAM Network: 6 x Gigabit Ethernet Storage: 1 x 320GB SATA hard disk Ports: VGA, 2 x USB2 Software: Windows Server 2008 Standard 64-bit, Microsoft Forefront TMG 2010 and Celestix Comet preloaded Options: Annual support from Wick Hill, from £419 ex VAT

Featured Resources

Key considerations for implementing secure telework at scale

Identifying the security risks and advanced requirements of a remote workforce

Download now

The State of Salesforce 2020

Your guide to getting the most from Salesforce

Download now

Fast, flexible and compliant e-signatures for global businesses

Be at the forefront of digital transformation with electronic signatures

Download now

Rethink your cybersecurity strategy for the new world

5 steps to secure the enterprise and be fit for a flexible future

Download now

Most Popular

How to find RAM speed, size and type
Laptops

How to find RAM speed, size and type

3 Aug 2020
How to use Chromecast without Wi-Fi
Mobile

How to use Chromecast without Wi-Fi

4 Aug 2020
How do I fix the Windows 10 Start Menu if it's frozen?
operating systems

How do I fix the Windows 10 Start Menu if it's frozen?

3 Aug 2020