IT Pro is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Inside the enterprise: eG8 - did you come here for an argument?

The row at the eG8 event between France's President Sarkozy and Google's Eric Schmidt shows two very different views of how the internet should be run.

Stephen Pritchard

To borrow a line from the old Monty Python sketch, it does rather seem as if France's President Sarkozy came to the eG8 event this week in search of a row. And delegates a list of the great and good of the online world did not disappoint.

In particular, Google's executive chairman, Eric Schmidt, responded firmly to accusations about privacy breaches, and the suggestion by Sarkozy that executives of online firms live in a "parallel universe, where legal and moral rules and, more generally, all the basic principles that govern society in democratic countries do not apply."

Schmidt, for his part, told the audience regulators would always be playing catch up with technology and the online industry should be given the time to solve security and privacy problems itself.

The argument illustrates two quite different views of how the online world should develop. France, for example, has a different approach to privacy than the US or the UK.

Successive French governments have criticised the internet for its Anglo-Saxon bias. Back in 2005, the then French president Jacques Chirac tried to push for a European alternative to Google, called Quaero. Despite receiving Government funding, much of it from France, the project failed to offer a real challenge to Google or even Bing, and is now largely focused on academic research.

So it is no surprise an e-society event in Paris would see Google and the French Government take largely opposing views.

But scepticism about the value and power of the internet is by no means the preserve of French senior politicians or senior public figures. Commenting on the repeated breach of super injunctions on the internet, and by Twitter users in particular, the Master of the Rolls, Lord Judge, described modern technology as "totally out of control."

The uncontrolled growth of the internet certainly raises some important issues around privacy, confidentiality and even security.

The challenge for law makers and regulators is to frame legislation broad enough to allow for technology change but drawn tightly enough so it does not stifle innovation, lead to laws being applied in ways that were never intended or even used to suppress individual or commercial freedom.

Google's Schmidt is also right to point out law makers will always be on the back foot when it comes to controlling technology. However, his argument for self regulation rests on the industry doing more to earn the public's trust. Google's own record on that score is by no means spotless.

Both companies that run internet services, such as Google and Facebook, and those enterprises making use of them, need to have a higher regard for privacy, security and the proper use of our data. If they do not, regulation will surely follow.

Stephen Pritchard is a contributing editor at IT PRO.

Comments? Questions? You can email him here

Featured Resources

The Total Economic Impact™ Of Turbonomic Application Resource Management for IBM Cloud® Paks

Business benefits and cost savings enabled by IBM Turbonomic Application Resource Management

Free Download

The Total Economic Impact™ of IBM Watson Assistant

Cost savings and business benefits enabled by Watson Assistant

Free Download

The field guide to application modernisation

Moving forward with your enterprise application portfolio

Free Download

AI for customer service

Discover the industry-leading AI platform that customers and employees want to use

Free Download

Recommended

Record for the largest ever HTTPS DDoS attack smashed once again
Network & Internet

Record for the largest ever HTTPS DDoS attack smashed once again

19 Aug 2022
Google adds prevalence visualisation, curated threat detection to Chronicle suite
cloud security

Google adds prevalence visualisation, curated threat detection to Chronicle suite

18 Aug 2022
Google is now spending a staggering amount on blockchain
Business strategy

Google is now spending a staggering amount on blockchain

17 Aug 2022
Google urges Apple to embrace RCS as standard, ditch SMS for Android texts
Mobile

Google urges Apple to embrace RCS as standard, ditch SMS for Android texts

10 Aug 2022

Most Popular

Apple patches 'superpower' zero-days affecting iPhones, iPads, and Macs
zero-day exploit

Apple patches 'superpower' zero-days affecting iPhones, iPads, and Macs

18 Aug 2022
Why convenience is the biggest threat to your security
Sponsored

Why convenience is the biggest threat to your security

8 Aug 2022
The benefits of a hardware update for SMBs
Sponsored

The benefits of a hardware update for SMBs

2 Aug 2022