EE 4G fieldtest results: Is it really as fast as the network claims?

We've tested out EE's 4G network around London using a Huawei Mobile Wi-Fi device and a Sony Xperia S.

The UK's first mobile 4G network and Fibre Broadband services were launched by EE on 30 October across 11 cities.

We got our hands on the portable Huawei Mobile Wi-Fi E589, which packs 4G connectivity and put it to the test in London to see just how fast it is.

How we tested?

We tethered the Mobile Wi-Fi device to the Sony Xperia S and tested it at seven locations. We aimed to get a diverse range of areas from one of the most busy train stations in London to a wide open space in Regents Park.

Advertisement - Article continues below

We started off at the Dennis Offices (Cleveland Street) and went to Canary Wharf (high-rise buildings), Kings Cross (busy station), London Bridge, Waterloo (both south of the river), Oxford Street (busy high street) and Regents Park (wide open space).

To test the download and upload speeds we used the Speedtest.net app. We took three readings at each location and then averaged it out.

To help corroborate download speeds we also timed how long it took to download a 200MB file at each location. This is typically the size of one 45-minute programme hosted on the BBC's iPlayer.

Results

We found average download speeds ranged between 2.44-15.91Mbps, a much broader range than EE touts (8-12Mbps). Most of our test results were on the lower end of the spectrum, which wasn't great and we got nowhere near the touted maximum speed of 40Mbps.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Unsurprisingly, we found that the more congested the location, the slower the download speeds as more people are using their devices. Regents Park offered the best download speeds, whereas Oxford Street was the slowest.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The test results from the Speedtest.net app were as follows:

Download Speeds

Our file test download backed up the Speedtest.net results when it came to download speeds, with the locations having the same order it terms of speed.

File download test

In terms of real-world performance this meant that it took just over three minutes to download 200MB at Regents Park - the area where we had the fastest connection. In comparison, it took over three times longer to download the same file at Oxford Street. At most of the other test locations it took just over five minutes.

In comparison, the results of the upload speeds were far more unpredictable. For example, upload speed at Oxford Street 9.99Mbps, was pretty much on par with Regents Park (10.05Mbps) even though there was a massive difference when it came to downloading content. There was also an unexplained peak at our office on Cleveland Street (16.91Mpbs).

On the plus side, we did find 4G upload speeds averaged between 7.7-16.91Mbps, which is well above the range quoted by EE (5-6Mpbs). This suggests that 4G is going to be much better for uploading documents and attachments than 3G.

Is it worth it?

With 24-month consumer contracts starting at 36 per month and including a monthly allowance of just 500MB, 4G is expensive considering the speed on offer. For SMBs, packages will start at 35 per month ex VAT.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Unless you splash out on the larger 4-8GB packages you could find yourself using up the allowance in minutes if you want to download video content, especially if it's HD.

If you commute into one of the major cities with 4G from surrounding towns, you'll drop down to HSPA+ connectivity.

Verdict

Unless you’re in urgent need for fast mobile upload speeds or plan to use wireless connectivity instead of fixed broadband, we’d recommend holding off until other networks such as Three start offering packages as the price across the board will most likely be driven down.

Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/mobile/mobile-networks/354944/birmingham-crowned-the-fastest-uk-city-for-4g-download-speeds
mobile networks

Birmingham crowned the fastest UK city for 4G download speeds

9 Mar 2020
Visit/mobile/28690/lte-vs-4g
Mobile

LTE vs 4G

16 Sep 2019

Most Popular

Visit/security/privacy/355211/google-releases-location-data-to-showcase-effectiveness-of-coronavirus
privacy

Google releases location data to show effectiveness of coronavirus lockdowns

3 Apr 2020
Visit/software/355113/companies-offering-free-software-to-fight-covid-19
Software

These are the companies offering free software during the coronavirus crisis

2 Apr 2020
Visit/data-insights/data-management/355170/oracle-cloud-courses-are-free-during-coronavirus-lockdown
data management

Oracle cloud courses are free during coronavirus lockdown

31 Mar 2020