Judge rejects Apple's bid to ban Samsung smartphone sales

Consumer electronics giant fails to win over judge during latest round of smartphone patent wars.

Copyright sign

A US judge has denied Apple's request for a permanent injunction against Samsung Electronics' smartphones, depriving the iPhone maker of a clear market advantage in the mobile patent wars.

Apple had been awarded $1.05 billion in damages in August after a US jury found Samsung had copied critical features of the iPhone and iPad. The Samsung products run on the Android operating system, developed by Google.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Apple and Samsung are going toe-to-toe in a patents dispute that mirrors the struggle for industry supremacy between the two companies, which control more than half of worldwide smartphone sales.

It does not follow that entire products must be forever banned because they incorporate a few narrow protected functions.

For most of the year, Apple had been successful in its US litigation campaign against Samsung. Apple convinced US District Judge Lucy Koh in San Jose, California, to impose two pretrial sales bans against Samsung - one against the Galaxy Tab 10.1, and the other against the Galaxy Nexus phone.

Apple then sought to keep up the pressure after its sweeping jury win. It asked Koh to impose a permanent sales ban against 26 mostly older Samsung phones, though any injunction could potentially have been extended to Samsung's newer Galaxy products.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Yet the jury exonerated Samsung on the patent used to ban Galaxy Tab 10.1 sales, and Koh rescinded that injunction. Then, in October, a federal appeals court reversed Koh's ban against the Nexus phone.

Advertisement - Article continues below

In her order late on Monday, Koh cited that appellate ruling as binding legal precedent, ruling that Apple had not presented enough evidence that its patented features drove consumer demand for the entire iPhone.

"The phones at issue in this case contain a broad range of features, only a small fraction of which are covered by Apple's patents," Koh wrote.

"Though Apple does have some interest in retaining certain features as exclusive to Apple," she continued, "it does not follow that entire products must be forever banned from the market because they incorporate, among their myriad features, a few narrow protected functions."

An Apple spokeswoman declined to comment on Koh's ruling, and a Samsung representative could not immediately be reached.

In a separate order on Monday, Koh rejected a bid by Samsung for a new trial based on an allegation that the jury foreman was improperly biased in favor of Apple.

Featured Resources

Key considerations for implementing secure telework at scale

Identifying the security risks and advanced requirements of a remote workforce

Download now

The State of Salesforce 2020

Your guide to getting the most from Salesforce

Download now

Fast, flexible and compliant e-signatures for global businesses

Be at the forefront of digital transformation with electronic signatures

Download now

Rethink your cybersecurity strategy for the new world

5 steps to secure the enterprise and be fit for a flexible future

Download now
Advertisement

Recommended

Windows will soon mirror smartphone apps on your PC
Microsoft Windows

Windows will soon mirror smartphone apps on your PC

6 Aug 2020
Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra hands-on review: Note so special
Google Android

Samsung Galaxy Note 20 Ultra hands-on review: Note so special

5 Aug 2020
Samsung Galaxy Note 20 hands-on review: A bronze medal smartphone
Google Android

Samsung Galaxy Note 20 hands-on review: A bronze medal smartphone

5 Aug 2020
Apple hit with $1.4 billion Siri patent infringement lawsuit
Policy & legislation

Apple hit with $1.4 billion Siri patent infringement lawsuit

3 Aug 2020

Most Popular

How to find RAM speed, size and type
Laptops

How to find RAM speed, size and type

3 Aug 2020
How to use Chromecast without Wi-Fi
Mobile

How to use Chromecast without Wi-Fi

4 Aug 2020
UN report points to a 350% rise in phishing websites at start of 2020
phishing

UN report points to a 350% rise in phishing websites at start of 2020

7 Aug 2020