Google's FTC pact could affect other patent disputes, it is claimed

Last week's ruling could have far-reaching consequences for smartphone makers, say analysts.

Man looking out to sea

While the focus of last week's agreement between the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and Google was search, the deal's restrictions on how the internet giant uses its patents could affect the whole technology industry.

Under the deal, which ended an antitrust investigation by the FTC and disappointed many critics, Google will make only minor changes to its search business.

Advertisement - Article continues below

But Google is also now limited in when it can seek injunctions against products from rival companies that use certain patents.

We know in today's world, defendants are getting more aggressive.

Throughout recent smartphone wars and other major patent litigation, holders of so-called standard essential patents have been accused of using them to bully competitors into paying high licensing rates or as leverage in patent disputes.

The FTC's deal with Google clarifies the uncertainty over how standard essential patents can be used, said Colleen Chien, a professor specialising in patent law at Santa Clara University School of Law in California.

The deal set out a process by which technology makers can avoid injunctions and patent holders know they are going to get compensated, Chien said. "The FTC has deflated the power of the injunction and also the incentives to not pay that have existed."

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

In its case against Google, the FTC claimed that Google and its subsidiary Motorola Mobility had breached commitments to standard-setting bodies to license its patents on terms that are fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory.

Advertisement - Article continues below

As part of the deal, Google agreed to drop claims for injunctive relief against competitors in certain patent disputes around the world. It also agreed to submit to the jurisdiction of a court or arbitrator when disputes over payment rates arise.

Throughout the FTC's investigation, Google was represented by Susan Creighton of Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati and John Harkrider of Axinn, Veltrop & Harkrider. The FTC retained Beth Wilkinson of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison.

Template

The FTC said the threat of injunction by a holder of an essential patent hurts competition. The agreement with Google could be used as a "template" for other patent disputes, it said.

Unlike a court decision, the FTC's agreement with Google is not binding on other companies. But it could give leverage to defendants in disputes with essential patent holders that could be used in court.

"We know in today's world, defendants are getting more aggressive," said Matthew Woods, an antitrust and patent attorney at Robins, Kaplan, Miller & Ciresi. "Defendants will seize on this and tell courts that injunctions are something the court should not even countenance."

Advertisement - Article continues below

But the agreement with Google may not be all good news for patent users, according to Jay Jurata, an antitrust partner at Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe, who said that it could have unintended consequences.

The elaborate agreement allows Google to seek injunctions against companies that are unwilling to pay for a license on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms.

But the question of when a company is considered an unwilling licensee is one that the FTC may have unwittingly allowed holders of essential patents to manipulate, said Jurata.

"They provided a road map for other standard essential patent holders to engage in opportunistic behavior to paint otherwise willing licensees as unwilling licensees," he said.

Featured Resources

Top 5 challenges of migrating applications to the cloud

Explore how VMware Cloud on AWS helps to address common cloud migration challenges

Download now

3 reasons why now is the time to rethink your network

Changing requirements call for new solutions

Download now

All-flash buyer’s guide

Tips for evaluating Solid-State Arrays

Download now

Enabling enterprise machine and deep learning with intelligent storage

The power of AI can only be realised through efficient and performant delivery of data

Download now
Advertisement
Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/cloud/cloud-backup/355025/google-backup-and-sync-review-that-syncing-feeling
cloud backup

Google Backup and Sync review: That syncing feeling

17 Mar 2020
Visit/mobile/google-android/354816/android-11-developer-access-arrives-earlier-than-expected
Google Android

Android 11 developer access arrives earlier than expected

20 Feb 2020
Visit/policy-legislation/data-protection/354814/google-to-shift-uk-user-data-to-the-us-post-brexit
data protection

Google to shift UK user data to the US post-Brexit

20 Feb 2020
Visit/hardware/routers/354782/google-nest-wifi-review-a-solid-improvement-but-not-for-long
routers

Google Nest Wifi review: A solid improvement, but not for long

14 Feb 2020

Most Popular

Visit/infrastructure/server-storage/355118/hpe-warns-of-critical-bug-that-destroys-ssds-after-40000-hours
Server & storage

HPE warns of 'critical' bug that destroys SSDs after 40,000 hours

26 Mar 2020
Visit/software/video-conferencing/355138/zoom-beaming-ios-user-data-to-facebook-for-targeted-ads
video conferencing

Zoom beams iOS user data to Facebook for targeted ads

27 Mar 2020
Visit/software/355113/companies-offering-free-software-to-fight-covid-19
Software

These are the companies offering free software during the coronavirus crisis

25 Mar 2020
Visit/mobile/mobile-phones/355088/apple-lifts-iphone-purchase-restrictions
Mobile Phones

Apple lifts iPhone purchase restrictions

23 Mar 2020