AI can predict 79% of human rights trial verdicts

A machine learning algorithm can predict outcomes of human rights trials


University researchers have developed an AI algorithm that predicted the verdict of European Court of Human Rights cases with 79% accuracy.

This AI used machine learning tools to reach a conclusion as to what the verdicts of the human rights cases it was presented with would be.

The researchers, from University College London (UCL), University of Sheffield and University of Pennsylvania, collaborated on this project, using their skills and expertise to develop an AI that can analyse case text through a machine learning algorithm.

Advertisement - Article continues below

It searched for patterns in 584 cases relating to three specific fundamental human rights articles, looking for potential violations of article three (involving torture or demeaning treatment), article six (the right to a fair trial), and article eight (the right to respect for private life).

Dr Nikolaos Aletras, who led the study at UCL, told the BBC: "There is a lot of hype about AI but we don't see it replacing judges or lawyers any time soon. What we do think is they'd find it useful for rapidly identifying patterns in cases that lead to certain outcomes."

The algorithm appeared to make most of its mistakes when two cases were very similar but only one was a violation of human rights. This could mean its algorithm found it harder to detect subtle differences in the law.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Some law firms, such as Baker & Hostetler, are already using AI tools to analyse large amounts of legal data.

Advertisement - Article continues below

However, some of these AIs might still come with limitations. Matt Jones, analyst at Tessella, told the BBC that "an AI can make a good guess but without direct appreciation of the wider context outside of its training data and experience, that guess may be widely off the mark, and in a legal situation that may be dangerous for the case".

Although many of these technologies might still need improvement, Dr Aletras believes that in future the AI his team developed could even help spot cases that are potentially violating the European Convention on Human Rights, hence tackling flaws in the judiciary system.

Featured Resources

Preparing for long-term remote working after COVID-19

Learn how to safely and securely enable your remote workforce

Download now

Cloud vs on-premise storage: What’s right for you?

Key considerations driving document storage decisions for businesses

Download now

Staying ahead of the game in the world of data

Create successful marketing campaigns by understanding your customers better

Download now

Transforming productivity

Solutions that facilitate work at full speed

Download now


Careers & training

The UK should follow Finland's lead with it comes to AI training

19 Dec 2019
Business strategy

What is machine learning?

27 Sep 2019
Marketing & comms

AI is just clever marketing, and I’m not buying

20 Sep 2019

AI can play poker, but I’m neither shaken nor stirred

16 Jul 2019

Most Popular

Business operations

Nvidia overtakes Intel as most valuable US chipmaker

9 Jul 2020

How to find RAM speed, size and type

24 Jun 2020

The best server solution for your SMB

26 Jun 2020