Oracle underpaid women and minorities by more than $400 million, says US government

Complaint claims Silicon Valley giant prefers hiring Asian students so it can underpay them

Oracle has been accused of underpaying its female and minority employees by over $400 million over a four-year period, adding to the allegations of rampant exploitation and discrimination at the company.

The news comes as part of an ongoing lawsuit against the Silicon Valley giant by the United States Department of Labor. The suit was initially filed in January 2017, and was sparked by an investigation into Oracle after it was awarded government contracts worth in excess of $100 million annually.

According to a new motion, Oracle's preference when recruiting was to hire Asian engineers with student visas. Due to the nature of these visas, the complaint says, these employees were "dependent upon Oracle for sponsorship" in order to stay in the country - allowing Oracle to underpay them, secure in the knowledge that they couldn't look for another job.

From 2013 to 2016, the US government claimed that Oracle's college recruitment program hired around 450 Asian employees, which made up 90% of the program's total capacity. Just six black people were hired by the program during the same time-frame.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement - Article continues below

In addition to this, Oracle also allegedly underpays its female, black and Asian staff compared to white men. The company sets starting salaries based on how much a new hire previously earned at their old job - a practise which is widely known to perpetuate wage discrimination by ensuring that unfair salaries are carried over to a new company. The motion also alleges that Oracle purposefully steers non-white, non-male employees into lower-paid roles, with some women making up to 20% less money for the same work in 2016.

The new allegations echo a class-action suit submitted just days ago, which seeks to represent more than 4,000 female employees which Oracle has supposedly underpaid by an average of $13,000 per year. That suit alleges that Oracle was aware of the issues, but failed to correct them.

"Oracle's suppression of pay for its non-White, non-male employees is so extreme that it persists and gets worse over long careers; female, Black, and Asian employees with years of experience are paid as much as 25% less than their peers," a new document filed yesterday in relation to the Department of Labor's case said. "Oracle's compensation practices cause an increasing pay gap as those employees devote more of their lives to Oracle."

The suit focuses on staff based at Oracle's California headquarters, in roles such as support, IT and product development. The department estimated that Oracle had underpaid its black, female and Asian staff by a collective total of $401 million, but noted that because it had continued underpaying them after the end of the period for which the department had records, the actual total is likely much higher. In fact, the department said that Oracle has either withheld or destroyed information which the company thought would look "unfavorable to Oracle".

Oracle could face stiff penalties if it loses the case; as well as having to repay lost wages to its affected employees, hire new staff to address the imbalance and alter its hiring practices to ensure this doesn't happen in future, the department is campaigning for Oracle's government contracts to be cancelled and for the company to be banned from future government contracts until it corrects its allegedly discriminatory practices.

As with the previous claims of discrimination on Monday, an Oracle spokesperson declined to comment on the new allegations.

Featured Resources

The IT Pro guide to Windows 10 migration

Everything you need to know for a successful transition

Download now

Managing security risk and compliance in a challenging landscape

How key technology partners grow with your organisation

Download now

Software-defined storage for dummies

Control storage costs, eliminate storage bottlenecks and solve storage management challenges

Download now

6 best practices for escaping ransomware

A complete guide to tackling ransomware attacks

Download now


Careers & training

Proportion of women in tech roles ‘flatlining’

5 Dec 2019
Business strategy

The IT Pro Podcast: How upskilling can improve diversity

15 Nov 2019
Business strategy

Oracle: Cultural resistance, not tech, is holding innovation

13 Feb 2019
Business strategy

Oracle accused of underpaying women by $13k per year

21 Jan 2019

Most Popular

Microsoft Windows

This exploit could give users free Windows 7 updates beyond 2020

9 Dec 2019

Patch issued for critical Windows bug

11 Dec 2019
Microsoft Azure

Microsoft, not Amazon, is going to win the cloud wars

30 Nov 2019
big data

Google reveals UK’s most searched for terms in 2019

11 Dec 2019