Oracle accused of coercing customers into cloud migrations

Google Cloud CEO named as a defendant in a German firm's third attempt to bring Oracle to court

Oracle is being sued for allegedly inflating cloud revenues and resorting to "systematically coercing and bribing" existing customers into cloud migrations.

This is according to a 164-page complaint filed to a Federal District Court in California by German-based Union Asset Management AG.

It's the third time that the company has sort to challenge Oracle in US courts having failed to get beyond the first hurdle in 2018 and 2019.

The report names founder Larry Ellison, CEO Safra Catz, former CEO, the late Mark Hurd, and claims that its top executives were "highly motivated to misleadingly inflate Oracle's Cloud revenues through the use of engineered deals by virtue of the company's compensation plan". 

The documents also name Oracle's former cloud boss, now Google Cloud CEO, Thomas Kurian as a defendant.

In the court filings, it states that Oracle employed a strategy known as Audit, Bargain, Close that it used to coerce cloud sales. With this Oracle would install its on-premise software in its existing client's ecosystems with preferences automatically enabled, which, according to the filing, would cause the customer to unknowingly exceed the limits of its license.

"After the customer fell into this trap, Oracle would audit the on-premises customer for violations of its on-premises software license," the filings said. "When it found violations, Oracle would threaten to impose extremely large penalties. Oracle would then offer to reduce or eliminate those penalties if the customer agreed to accept a short-term cloud subscription that the customer neither desired nor intended to use."

The documents also quote a 2017 email from Kurain, sent while working at Oracle. In the email, he is critical of the interface for Oracle Human Capital Management Cloud, calling it a "disgrace".

"I continue to get extraordinary pressure from our two CEOs [Mark Hurd and Safra Catz] and LJE [Larry Ellison] himself that the UI is not tenable... the core product UI is awful. Until you all collectively accept the mess you have made and the need to move quickly we are talking past one another."

In June 2018 the tech giant changed the way it reported cloud revenues every quarter by only putting forward a combined figure for SaaS, PaaS and IaaS. IT Pro has approached Oracle for a response. 

Featured Resources

How to scale your organisation in the cloud

How to overcome common scaling challenges and choose the right scalable cloud service

Download now

The people factor: A critical ingredient for intelligent communications

How to improve communication within your business

Download now

Future of video conferencing

Optimising video conferencing features to achieve business goals

Download now

Improving cyber security for remote working

13 recommendations for security from any location

Download now

Recommended

Modern networking for the borderless enterprise
Whitepaper

Modern networking for the borderless enterprise

3 Mar 2021
The care and feeding of cloud
Whitepaper

The care and feeding of cloud

24 Feb 2021
Address multi-cloud configuration risks
Whitepaper

Address multi-cloud configuration risks

24 Feb 2021
Atlassian’s new cloud offering addresses enterprises’ core needs
cloud management

Atlassian’s new cloud offering addresses enterprises’ core needs

18 Feb 2021

Most Popular

How to find RAM speed, size and type
Laptops

How to find RAM speed, size and type

26 Feb 2021
How to connect one, two or more monitors to your laptop
Laptops

How to connect one, two or more monitors to your laptop

25 Feb 2021
Ransomware operators are exploiting VMware ESXi flaws
ransomware

Ransomware operators are exploiting VMware ESXi flaws

1 Mar 2021