AWS "likely to succeed" in JEDI appeal

The judge responsible for halting the project says that Microsoft's price scenario was not "technically feasible"

The Department of Defence (DoD) improperly evaluated a Microsoft storage price scenario, the US judge that halted work on the JEDI contract has said.

Federal Claims Judge Patricia Cambell-Smith added that because of this AWS is "likely to succeed" in its court challenge, according to Reuters.

The Joint Enterprise Defence Infrastructure project, awarded to Microsoft in October, is a $10 billion project to migrate the DoD's computer systems. It has been marred in controversy from the start, with companies like IBM and Oracle attempting legal action over its single-vendor nature.

A large part of AWS' complaint was that the bidding process was unfairly influenced by US President Donald Trump, but that was not mentioned in the Judge's opinion.

Campbell-Smith wrote that Amazon "is likely to succeed on the merits of its argument that the DoD improperly evaluated" a Microsoft price scenario. She added that the scenario assessed by the Pentagon was not "technically feasible".

In response, Microsoft dismissed the decision as it focused on a "lone technical finding" of data storage under one price scenario out of six, according to Reuters. The company is confident it would eventually be able to move on with the project.

"The government makes clear that in their view Microsoft's solution met the technical standards and performed as needed," a Microsoft spokesperson said.

This could be seen as the first real tech-related argument of the JEDI saga, with large sections of the lawsuit focusing on the alleged interference of US President Donald Trump, who reportedly became concerned with the bidding when other cloud providers complained of being unfairly excluded.

Trump also has a long-running feud with Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos, which is seen as a possible reason for his alleged involvement. Former Pentagon Secretary James Mattis is thought to have said that Trump directed him to "screw Amazon" out of a chance to bid on the contract.

Featured Resources

How to choose an AI vendor

Five key things to look for in an AI vendor

Download now

The UK 2020 Databerg report

Cloud adoption trends in the UK and recommendations for cloud migration

Download now

2021 state of email security report: Ransomware on the rise

Securing the enterprise in the COVID world

Download now

The impact of AWS in the UK

How AWS is powering Britain's fastest-growing companies

Download now

Most Popular

Q&A: Enabling transformation
Sponsored

Q&A: Enabling transformation

10 Jun 2021
How to find RAM speed, size and type
Laptops

How to find RAM speed, size and type

16 Jun 2021
Millions of Volkswagen customers affected by data breach
data breaches

Millions of Volkswagen customers affected by data breach

14 Jun 2021