Government will create 'a two-tier data protection system', campaigners warn

Privacy groups vow to challenge an exemption to the Data Protection Bill if it becomes law

Digital rights campaigners have threatened to launch legal action over plans that would prevent three million EU citizens from accessing personal data the government holds on them.

The potential lawsuit concerns the government's Data Protection Bill, which proposes to replicate most of the EU's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) into UK law to ensure data can continue to flow freely between the UK and EU post-Brexit.

GDPR comes into force on 25 May, and will allow EU residents to demand that organisations delete, amend and move any data they hold on residents, as well as tell residents what information they have on them and why they have it.

But the bill, being debated in Parliament today, currently includes proposals for an exemption clause that privacy campaigners argue is incompatible with the principles of GDPR, by effectively excluding 3 million EU citizens living in the UK from bring able to challenge such data held by immigration authorities.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement - Article continues below

The clause (Schedule 2, Paragraph 4 of the bill) would prevent these citizens from challenging the Home Office over any deportation decisions, campaigners say, because they could not debate the accuracy of any information the Home Office holds on them.

That's because the bill provides an exemption for data relevant to "effective immigration control", and because instead of confirming the existing rights of EU citizens living in the UK, the government instead wants them to apply for a new immigration status, meaning any error made by the Home Office in that process would go unchallenged by those it affects.

As a result 3million, a grassroots organisation representing EU citizens resident in the UK, and privacy campaign organisation Open Rights Group (ORG), will challenge the clause in court if it is enshrined in law.

Rosa Curling, a human rights solicitor from law firm Leigh Day, representing the two groups, said: "The immigration exemption creates a discriminatory twotier system for data protection rights. The clause is incompatible with GDPR, as well as EU law generally and the European Convention on Human Rights.

"If the exemption is made law, our clients will apply for judicial review. They have written to the government today to urge it to reconsider and to remove the immigration exemption from the bill without further delay."

"This is an attempt to disguise the Home Office's mistakes by making sure that their errors are never found," added Jim Killock, ORG executive director. "When people are wrongly told to leave, they would find it very hard to challenge.

Advertisement - Article continues below

"Data protection is a basic safeguard to make sure you can find out what organisations know about you, and why they make decisions. Sometimes, during criminal investigations, that isn't appropriate, but immigrants aren't criminals, nor should they be treated as such."

Nicolas Hatton, chairman of the3million, argued that further government proposals to set up a new registration system for EU citizens living in the UK after it leaves the EU would "potentially create a database with the personal details of over three million people".

"We need safeguards in place to ensure that these citizens have access to the information held about them, so they are able to appeal Home Office decisions or correct mistakes," he added. "Everyone should be entitled to know how the Home Office and other government agencies are using their records, and that is why we want this exemption removed."

A government spokesperson told the Guardian: "The bill carefully balances protecting people's data rights and the wider interests of society including making sure day-to-day operations relating to immigration controls are not obstructed. There are no blanket exemptions: any restrictions will need to be justified on a case-by-case basis with oversight from the Information Commissioner's Office and the courts."

Featured Resources

What you need to know about migrating to SAP S/4HANA

Factors to assess how and when to begin migration

Download now

Your enterprise cloud solutions guide

Infrastructure designed to meet your company's IT needs for next-generation cloud applications

Download now

Testing for compliance just became easier

How you can use technology to ensure compliance in your organisation

Download now

Best practices for implementing security awareness training

How to develop a security awareness programme that will actually change behaviour

Download now


data management

EU-US data transfer tools used by Facebook ruled legal

19 Dec 2019

Arcserve UDP 9240DR review: Beef up your backups

4 Apr 2019

Most Popular

data governance

Brexit security talks under threat after UK accused of illegally copying Schengen data

10 Jan 2020
cyber security

If not passwords then what?

8 Jan 2020
Policy & legislation

GDPR and Brexit: How will one affect the other?

9 Jan 2020
web browser

What is HTTP error 503 and how do you fix it?

7 Jan 2020