Labour's digital review: The good and the bad

Why Labour's digital review is right about focusing on skills, and wrong about expanding the GDS

Open digital architecture

 Labour is just as keen as the Coalition to establish Government-as-a-Platform. This approach would see public data opened up for sharing among departments to create better services, though TechMarketView's O'Toole identifies challenges to this approach.

"We see issues around the handling and analysing of personal data, and the benefits and limitations of big data and open data, as the biggest hurdle to Government-as-a-Platform," she explains. "There is still a quagmire to wade through. The review recognises that and recommends a new legislative framework."

One approach Labour is passionate about is to give people ownership of their own data, but Kable's Roberts is sceptical.

He says: "Ensuring people own their own data' is question-begging, but there clearly needs to be well publicised and understood safeguards around initiatives like care.data.

"As solutions to these issues tend to be carefully nuanced, and the public debate tends to be shrill and crude, it's difficult to believe that legislative actions would resolve the various issues."

IT industry trade body TechUK hopes establishing a data ethics committee could strengthen public trust in government data-handling.

Deputy CEO Antony Walker says: "We reiterate our call to establish an independent data ethics committee to ensure consistent compliance to appropriate ethical standards in order to strengthen public trust in the Government's use of data."

Meanwhile Chris Pennell, analyst at Ovum, believes opening up more data does not necessarily lead to better sharing, as that data could all be in different, non-compatible formats.

"An open address dataset does nothing to address data quality issues across government," he says. "This can only come from seeing data for the increasingly mission critical asset that it is, and treating it in such a manner."

Featured Resources

B2B under quarantine

Key B2C e-commerce features B2B need to adopt to survive

Download now

The top three IT pains of the new reality and how to solve them

Driving more resiliency with unified operations and service management

Download now

The five essentials from your endpoint security partner

Empower your MSP business to operate efficiently

Download now

How fashion retailers are redesigning their digital future

Fashion retail guide

Download now

Recommended

Department of Health and Human Services must improve cyber security info sharing
Security

Department of Health and Human Services must improve cyber security info sharing

30 Jun 2021
JEDI contract's future becomes murky after AWS court win
Policy & legislation

JEDI contract's future becomes murky after AWS court win

11 May 2021
Trump's election defeat isn't going to get Huawei back in the UK
Security

Trump's election defeat isn't going to get Huawei back in the UK

17 Nov 2020
TechUK panel slams "woeful" gov response to digital IDs
identity and access management (IAM)

TechUK panel slams "woeful" gov response to digital IDs

4 Sep 2020

Most Popular

The benefits of workload optimisation
Sponsored

The benefits of workload optimisation

16 Jul 2021
Samsung Galaxy S21 5G review: A rose-tinted experience
Mobile Phones

Samsung Galaxy S21 5G review: A rose-tinted experience

14 Jul 2021
IT Pro Panel: Why IT leaders need soft skills
professional development

IT Pro Panel: Why IT leaders need soft skills

26 Jul 2021