Brother MFC-J491DW review: Underwhelming for the price

This A4 inkjet isn’t bad, but there are much better alternatives

On paper, Brother's MFC-J491DW looks like it has everything you need from a home office multifunction device. This compact A4 colour inkjet combines printer, scanner, fax and copier functions, and connects to a wireless network. It can print double-sided, and its 20-sheet ADF helps with multipage copies and faxes.

In the flesh, it's less convincing. The clattery and flexible 100-sheet paper tray is the most obvious culprit, but there's a lack of polish when compared to rival MFPs. For example, the ink tanks aren't physically keyed, so it's possible to insert the wrong colour if you're not paying attention. It's also a squat, boxy affair that doesn't particularly inspire even by the comparatively low standards of printer design.

There are neat touches: the ADF folds away into the top panel when you're not using it and you can take direct control via a compact colour screen and conventional buttons. It's more cluttered than a touchscreen, but still easy to use.

The MFC-J491DW is typically in less of a hurry than you are. It delivered a first page of text in just ten seconds but reached only 10.9ppm over our full 25-page test, rising to 13.9ppm in draft mode. At 2.6ppm, colour graphics were slow, as was a 1.8ppm result when printing double-sided. Single mono copies took 17 seconds, with colour pages taking twice as long. Using the ADF, a ten-page mono single-sided copy needed two and a half minutes, and just under three minutes in colour.

By comparison, scans were quick, with a 150dpi A4 image needing 14 seconds, and even a detailed 1,200dpi 10 x 15cm photo scan completed in under a minute.

Unfortunately, our results didn't impress. Plain paper text quality was fine, but graphics lacked punch, looking a little washed out. Black photocopies were acceptable, but colour copies were more drab than the originals. Most photo prints suffered the same fate, too. Scans were also a little disappointing, with sharp focus but a loss of detail among dark shades.

Overall, the MFC-J491DW doesn't do much wrong, but it doesn't excel anywhere either. At this price, it's simply too lacklustre to compete.

Verdict

This A4 inkjet MFP may be cheap, but don’t let that fool you - the compromises made do not equate to good value. You’re better off spending a little more to get a much more satisfying result

Max print resolution

6,000 x 1,200dpi

Dimensions

400 x 341 x 172mm

Paper capacity

Tray (100)

Cost per page (standard, mono)

2.9p

Weight

8.3kg

Featured Resources

B2B under quarantine

Key B2C e-commerce features B2B need to adopt to survive

Download now

The top three IT pains of the new reality and how to solve them

Driving more resiliency with unified operations and service management

Download now

The five essentials from your endpoint security partner

Empower your MSP business to operate efficiently

Download now

How fashion retailers are redesigning their digital future

Fashion retail guide

Download now

Recommended

Canon PIXMA GM2050 Inkjet Monochrome Printer review: Less is more
peripherals

Canon PIXMA GM2050 Inkjet Monochrome Printer review: Less is more

8 Jul 2021
The IT Pro Podcast: Is it time to give up on the paperless office?
document management systems (DMS)

The IT Pro Podcast: Is it time to give up on the paperless office?

28 May 2021
HP’s new print solutions support a hybrid workforce
Hardware

HP’s new print solutions support a hybrid workforce

12 May 2021
Best printers 2021
Hardware

Best printers 2021

19 Mar 2021

Most Popular

The benefits of workload optimisation
Sponsored

The benefits of workload optimisation

16 Jul 2021
Samsung Galaxy S21 5G review: A rose-tinted experience
Mobile Phones

Samsung Galaxy S21 5G review: A rose-tinted experience

14 Jul 2021
Six ways boards can step up support for cyber security
Business strategy

Six ways boards can step up support for cyber security

22 Jul 2021