NHS-Alexa partnership ‘data protection disaster waiting to happen’

Health data will feed into Amazon's voice assistant but concerns mount over the fate of patient recordings

The Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) has entered into an open collaboration with Amazon to feed sensitive data into the software powering its Alexa virtual assistant.

With access to information held on the NHS website, the government hopes the artificial intelligence (AI) algorithm used by Alexa could generate more accurate guidance for individuals who make voice requests.

The widespread use of this technology, in turn, could potentially reduce the pressure on NHS clinicians and GPs by giving patients access to remedies for common illnesses. Example queries, the government has said, include: "Alexa, how do I treat a migraine?" and "Alexa, what are the symptoms of chickenpox?"

While the government has heralded the move as an example of pure clinical innovation, privacy campaigners have highlighted the data protection risks associated with integrating sensitive health queries with a commercial entity.

The shadow culture secretary and digital rights campaigner Tom Watson MP, for example, branded the move "the beginning of Mission Creep".

"The giant data monopolies want one thing: more and more data to drive their huge profits," Watson said. "Entrusting Amazon's Alexa to dispense health advice to patients simply opens the door to the holy grail - our NHS data."

Concerns around the move primarily centre on how patients' records are to be stored, for what purposes, and whether these will be exploited commercially. However, the health secretary Matt Hancock MP insisted the data is not commercialised, and that it will be encrypted.

"There are millions of people who have Alexa in their home, and they turn to Alexa and ask Alexa for medical advice," Hancock said in an interview with the BBC's Today Programme.

"I want the very best advice on Alexa and I want the very best advice on other tech platforms too. Providing the NHS advice which, of course, is provided for free, is because we want to make sure when people ask for medical advice they get the best advice.

"The privacy element of this is very important and there's a clear protocol in place that Amazon has, and indeed that we have within the NHS for the storage of data.

"But the data point, really, that has to be dealt with, but it can't take away from using modern technology so that if people want to they can get the very best advice, as well, of course, as always being able to see your GP face to face if you'd like."

Also speaking with the BBC, privacy group Big Brother Watch branded the move "a data protection disaster waiting to happen".

"Any public money spent on this awful plan rather than frontline services would be a breathtaking waste," its director Silkie Carlo said. "Healthcare is made inaccessible when trust and privacy is stripped away, and that's what this terrible plan would do."

Amazon has argued against these suggestions, indicating the information is not shared with third-parties or fed into what could amount to individual health profiles for customers. Moreover, the company says it enforces multi-factor authentication to restrict access, as well as encrypting the data.

The move forms part of the NHS' long-term plan for digital transformation across the entire health service. A report published earlier this year highlighted the need to implement more technologies within the NHS, as well as boost digital skills across the organisation.

"Customer trust is of the utmost importance, and Amazon take privacy seriously," a company spokesperson said.

"Customers are in control of their voice history. They can review and delete voice recordings in the Alexa App or by visiting amazon.co.uk/privacy. They can also opt-in to "delete what I just said" or "delete what I said today".

The NHS remains in discussions with other tech companies over the use of feed health data into the software powering rival voice assistants, like Microsoft's Cortana.

Featured Resources

Preparing for AI-enabled cyber attacks

MIT technology review insights

Download now

Cloud storage performance analysis

Storage performance and value of the IONOS cloud Compute Engine

Download now

The Forrester Wave: Top security analytics platforms

The 11 providers that matter most and how they stack up

Download now

Harness data to reinvent your organisation

Build a data strategy for the next wave of cloud innovation

Download now

Recommended

Four reasons your digital transformation project could fail
digital transformation

Four reasons your digital transformation project could fail

7 Jun 2021
What is digital transformation?
Business strategy

What is digital transformation?

1 Dec 2020

Most Popular

RMIT to be first Australian university to implement AWS supercomputing facility
high-performance computing (HPC)

RMIT to be first Australian university to implement AWS supercomputing facility

28 Jul 2021
Samsung Galaxy S21 5G review: A rose-tinted experience
Mobile Phones

Samsung Galaxy S21 5G review: A rose-tinted experience

14 Jul 2021
Zyxel USG Flex 200 review: A timely and effective solution
Security

Zyxel USG Flex 200 review: A timely and effective solution

28 Jul 2021