Snooper’s Charter fails to protect privacy, warn MPs

Intelligence and Security Committee criticises Investigatory Powers Bill

The Investigatory Powers Bill would fail to protect UK citizens from mass surveillance, according to a Parliamentary committee's damning report on the government's proposed new law.

The Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC) today demanded "substantive amendments" to the bill, also known as the Snooper's Charter.

If passed in its current guise, the bill would see internet service providers forced to store people's internet connection records (ICRs) for 12 months, while security products would have compulsory backdoors built in for government spies to access data.

Advertisement - Article continues below

MPs and peers on the committee claimed that those behind the legislation appeared not to know what the bill is meant to achieve.

"Overall, the privacy protections are inconsistent and in our view need strengthening," said the report, adding that the bill itself was a "significant missed opportunity" and took a "piecemeal" approach to protecting privacy.

The committee said that privacy should be "an integral part of the legislation rather than an add-on".

It added that checks and balances must be set up to oversee security services' powers to collect bulk data from internet users. 

The report also focused on rules that force companies to build backdoors into encrypted services, saying the bill was unclear on how warrants to access the backdoors might work, and that the committee was "not convinced as to the requirement for them".

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Dominic Grieve, the Conservative chairman of the ISC, said: "Taken as a whole, the draft bill fails to deliver the clarity that is so badly needed in this area."

Advertisement - Article continues below

"The issues under consideration are undoubtedly complex, however, it has been evident that even those working on the legislation have not always been clear as to what the provisions are intended to achieve."

He added: "The draft bill appears to have suffered from a lack of sufficient time and preparation."

Antony Walker, deputy CEO of industry trade body techUK, said that the bill lacks clarity on fundamental issues, such as core definitions of key terms, encryption, and equipment interference.

"Our members are unsure exactly what is meant by internet connection records (ICRs), how they will be gathered, stored and accessed. This kind of detail is crucial to understanding the impact of the proposed bill," he said.

Walker said anything that forces companies to create or allow vulnerabilities in their systems is a huge concern and could damage public trust and have a direct impact on global perception of the UK as a home for innovation and investment.

"These concerns are reinforced by the ISC report, which calls for clarity on the effect on end to end encryption, and we urge the Home Office to take its findings on board," he added.

Featured Resources

Top 5 challenges of migrating applications to the cloud

Explore how VMware Cloud on AWS helps to address common cloud migration challenges

Download now

3 reasons why now is the time to rethink your network

Changing requirements call for new solutions

Download now

All-flash buyer’s guide

Tips for evaluating Solid-State Arrays

Download now

Enabling enterprise machine and deep learning with intelligent storage

The power of AI can only be realised through efficient and performant delivery of data

Download now
Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/security/cyber-security/355185/165-million-britons-experienced-a-cyber-crime-in-the-past-year
cyber security

Report: 16.5 million Britons fell victim to cyber crime in the past year

1 Apr 2020
Visit/cloud/amazon-web-services-aws/355183/aws-launches-amazon-detective
Amazon Web Services (AWS)

AWS launches Amazon Detective for investigating security incidents

1 Apr 2020
Visit/security/privacy/355182/government-to-launch-coronavirus-contact-tracking-app
privacy

UK government to launch coronavirus 'contact tracking' app

1 Apr 2020
Visit/software/video-conferencing/355180/zoom-does-not-use-end-to-end-encrypted
video conferencing

Zoom admits meetings don't use end-to-end encryption

1 Apr 2020

Most Popular

Visit/security/cyber-crime/355171/fbi-warns-of-zoom-bombing-hackers-amidst-coronavirus-usage-spike
cyber crime

FBI warns of ‘Zoom-bombing’ hackers amid coronavirus usage spike

31 Mar 2020
Visit/security/data-breaches/355173/marriott-hit-by-data-breach-exposing-personal-data-of-52-million
data breaches

Marriott data breach exposes personal data of 5.2 million guests

31 Mar 2020
Visit/development/application-programming-interface-api/355192/apple-buys-dark-sky-weather-app-and-leaves
application programming interface (API)

Apple buys Dark Sky weather app and leaves Android users in the cold

1 Apr 2020
Visit/data-insights/data-management/355170/oracle-cloud-courses-are-free-during-coronavirus-lockdown
data management

Oracle cloud courses are free during coronavirus lockdown

31 Mar 2020