Home Office faces EU court battle over Snooper’s Charter

ECJ emergency hearing could shoot down Investigatory Powers Bill

The European Court of Justice (ECJ) is set to scrutinise the UK government's plans for bulk data collection and retention at an emergency hearing on 12 April.

Its intervention was demanded by the Court of Appeal of England and Wales to help decidewhether existing government spying measures are incompatible withthe Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union.

Depending on the outcome of the hearing, the ECJ could scupper the government's plans to pass the Investigatory Powers Bill into law.

The Court of Appeal asked the ECJ to examine a casebrought by MPs Tom Watson and David Davis and their co-claimants, Peter Brice and Geoffrey Lewis, against Home Secretary Theresa May'sData Retention and Investigatory Powers Act 2014 (DRIPA).

DRIPA is a piece of emergency legislation that came into force in July 2014 and expires on 31 December 2016 that governs the interception of electronic communications data.

Watson, Davis, and their fellow claimants argued that two sections of DRIPA - Section 1 (powers for retention of relevant communications data subject safeguards) and Section 2 (definitions of the terms used in section one) -were unlawfulbecause they are incompatible with EU Charter articles outlining respect for private and family life and the protection of personal data.

In mid-2015, the High Court of England and Wales ruled in the claimants' favour.The Home Secretary appealed this decision, which would have seen a time limit for the enforcement of the unlawful sections run out on Thursday of this week.

The government hopes that the Investigatory Powers Bill, which would compelinternet service providers to keep aspects of people's web browsing histories for 12 months, will replace DRIPA, but if the ECJ upholds the High Court's ruling, it could mean that the Investigatory Powers Bill is also incompatible with people's rights to privacy and data protection.

The bill is currently making its way through Parliament, under accusations that the government is trying to rush it into law.

It is now a three-way race to see which will happen first: Investigatory Powers receiving Royal Assent and becoming law, the ECJ issuing its ruling on the DRIPA case, or the EU referendum to decide whether or not the UK remains in the EU.

Read more about the Investigatory Powers Bill and its potential effect on businesses, the tech industry and privacy.

Featured Resources

BCDR buyer's guide for MSPs

How to choose a business continuity and disaster recovery solution

Download now

The definitive guide to IT security

Protecting your MSP and your customers

Download now

Cost of a data breach report 2020

Find out what factors help mitigate breach costs

Download now

The complete guide to changing your phone system provider

Optimise your phone system for better business results

Download now

Most Popular

16 ways to speed up your laptop
Laptops

16 ways to speed up your laptop

29 Apr 2021
How to move Windows 10 from your old hard drive to SSD
operating systems

How to move Windows 10 from your old hard drive to SSD

30 Apr 2021
Dell patches vulnerability affecting hundreds of computer models worldwide
cyber security

Dell patches vulnerability affecting hundreds of computer models worldwide

5 May 2021