Data guardian criticises DeepMind data sharing with NHS

National Data Guardian writes to hospital over data sharing with Google-owned company

The legal justification used for sharing patient data from a London NHS hospital to Google-owned DeepMind wasn't valid, according to the National Data Guardian. 

Health-data watchdog Dame Fiona Caldicott expressed her legal opinion of the controversial DeepMind data sharing deal in a letter to the head of the Royal Free NHS trust, after being asked for advice from the Information Commissioner, Elizabeth Denham.

Advertisement - Article continues below

The NHS trust teamed up with the deep-learning firm to trial a kidney app called Streams, which is designed to predict organ failure and avoid patient illness. As part of that, the trust shared 1.6 million patient records with the Google-owned British startup, a data-sharing move that was called "inexcusable" by academics who examined the deal. 

Now, it appears our National Data Guardian agrees. Writing to Stephen Powis, medical director at the Royal Free NHS Trust, Caldicott particularly criticised the justification for the data sharing, saying it was implied that it was for patient care - but she noted that's not what the Streams trial was actually about. 

"Taking into account what you have now clarified, it is my view and that of my panel that the purpose for the transfer of 1.6 million identifiable patient records to Google DeepMind was for the testing of the Streams application, and not for the provision of direct care to patients," Calidcott said in the letter, shared Hal Hodson, who initially revealed the data sharing agreement while a New Scientist reporter, and who also co-authored the aforementioned paper. 

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement - Article continues below

"Given that Streams was going through testing and therefore could not be relied upon for patient care, any role the application might have played in supporting the provision of direct care would have been limited and secondary to the purpose of the data transfer," she wrote. "My considered opinion therefore remains that it would not have been within the reasonable expectation of patients that their records would have been shared for this purpose."

Caldicott has shared that opinion with the Information Commissioner as part of the data watchdog's investigation. 

Caldicott added that guidance would be "useful" to organisations looking to test such technologies with patient data, and stressed that her and her panel of experts "keenly appreciate the great benefits that new technologies such as Streams can offer to patients". 

However, she stressed that misusing patient data could delay the use of such technologies. "As I know you also appreciate, wherever patient data is used, it is absolutely paramount that this is done in a transparent and secure manner, which helps to build public trust, otherwise the full benefits of such developments will not be realised, and indeed harm may be done."

DeepMind altered its data-sharing setup with the NHS after the initial round of complaints, and has since set up more trials.

Featured Resources

Top 5 challenges of migrating applications to the cloud

Explore how VMware Cloud on AWS helps to address common cloud migration challenges

Download now

3 reasons why now is the time to rethink your network

Changing requirements call for new solutions

Download now

All-flash buyer’s guide

Tips for evaluating Solid-State Arrays

Download now

Enabling enterprise machine and deep learning with intelligent storage

The power of AI can only be realised through efficient and performant delivery of data

Download now
Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/policy-legislation/data-protection/355184/supreme-court-finds-morrisons-was-not-liable-for-2014
data protection

Supreme Court rules Morrisons was not liable for 2014 data breach

1 Apr 2020
Visit/business/business-operations/355147/amazon-and-microsoft-join-nhs-project-battling-pandemic
Business operations

Amazon and Microsoft join NHS project battling pandemic

27 Mar 2020
Visit/security/privacy/355048/government-may-trace-covid-19-patients-using-mobile-phone-data
privacy

UK government may trace COVID-19 patients using mobile phone data

20 Mar 2020
Visit/security/cyber-security/355041/critical-nhs-cyber-security-checks-suspended-due-to-coronavirus
cyber security

Critical NHS cyber security checks suspended due to coronavirus response

19 Mar 2020

Most Popular

Visit/security/privacy/355155/zoom-kills-facebook-integration-after-data-transfer-backlash
privacy

Zoom kills Facebook integration after data transfer backlash

30 Mar 2020
Visit/security/data-breaches/355173/marriott-hit-by-data-breach-exposing-personal-data-of-52-million
data breaches

Marriott data breach exposes personal data of 5.2 million guests

31 Mar 2020
Visit/security/cyber-crime/355171/fbi-warns-of-zoom-bombing-hackers-amidst-coronavirus-usage-spike
cyber crime

FBI warns of ‘Zoom-bombing’ hackers amid coronavirus usage spike

31 Mar 2020
Visit/data-insights/data-management/355170/oracle-cloud-courses-are-free-during-coronavirus-lockdown
data management

Oracle cloud courses are free during coronavirus lockdown

31 Mar 2020