FBI needs a warrant to hack your computer, judge rules

A US federal judge has ruled that computer hacking legally counts as a search

Hacking someone's computer legally counts as a search when done by law enforcement, a Texas federal judge has ruled.

The decision comes as part of the ongoing court case relating to a dark web child porn site called Playpen. As part of the investigation, the FBI covertly implanted malware known as a Network Investigative Technique - or NIT - onto the computers of anyone who visited the site.

Jeffrey Torres of San Antonio, Texas, was one of the people caught in the FBI's cyber-sting. He filed a motion to suppress evidence seized from his home, based on the argument that the FBI's initial search of his computer was unlawful.

Judge David Alan Ezra ultimately denied the motion, ruling that the search was covered by the FBI's initial warrant. However, the ruling does clearly state that law enforcement hacking counts as a search under the fourth amendment of the US constitution.

"The NIT placed code on Mr. Torres' computer without his permission, causing it to transmit his IP address and other identifying data to the government," Ezra wrote in his ruling, stating that "this was unquestionably a 'search' for Fourth Amendment purposes".

This means that US authorities must possess a valid search warrant before hacking a suspect's computer - which marks a major win for privacy campaigners.

Legal opinion on this topic has been divided, however, and as part of a case relating to the same FBI operation, a Virginia District Judge ruled that the government needed no warrant in order to hack a defendant's computer.

The issue has presented a tricky problem for the courts, and according to Ezra, "has brought to light the need for Congressional clarification" regarding a judge's ability to issue warrants in cyber crime cases where the suspects may be using services like Tor to obscure their location.

Featured Resources

BIOS security: The next frontier for endpoint protection

Today’s threats upend traditional security measures

Download now

The role of modern storage in a multi-cloud future

Research exploring the impact of modern storage in defining cloud success

Download now

Enterprise data protection: A four-step plan

An interactive buyers’ guide and checklist

Download now

The total economic impact of Adobe Sign

Cost savings and business benefits enabled by Adobe Sign

Download now

Recommended

8 of the most secure web browsers
web browser

8 of the most secure web browsers

25 Sep 2020
Your essential guide to internet security
Security

Your essential guide to internet security

23 Sep 2020
How to enable private browsing on any device
privacy

How to enable private browsing on any device

22 Sep 2020
Third-party apps are tracking your WhatsApp activity
social media

Third-party apps are tracking your WhatsApp activity

21 Sep 2020

Most Popular

16 ways to speed up your laptop
Laptops

16 ways to speed up your laptop

16 Sep 2020
16 ways to speed up your laptop
Laptops

16 ways to speed up your laptop

16 Sep 2020
Google removes 17 apps infected with evasive ‘Joker’ malware
malware

Google removes 17 apps infected with evasive ‘Joker’ malware

28 Sep 2020