‘National security’ can’t be used as an excuse to bypass privacy laws

A preliminary ECJ ruling would limit the power of member states to sidestep privacy and data protection laws

EU member states might no longer be able to cite national security concerns as the basis for flouting data protection and privacy laws in the bulk collection of personal data, according to a preliminary legal judgement.

Security services should not have a blanket power to demand the personal and communications data of citizens from telecoms and tech companies, according to the European Court of Justice (ECJ) advocate general Campos Sanchez-Bordona.

Activities aimed at safeguarding national security - and that don’t rely on the co-operation of third parties - are exempt from the Directive on privacy and electronic communications, the advocate general has said. There are, however, complications that arise when private companies and other organisations are imposed upon by member states to hand over personal and private data.

“When the cooperation of private parties, on whom certain obligations are imposed, is required, even when that is on grounds of national security, that brings those activities into an area governed by EU law: the protection of privacy enforceable against those private actors,” his opinion states.

Related Resource

Testing for compliance just became easier

How you can use technology to ensure compliance in your organisation

Download now

“Accordingly, the Directive is applicable, in principle, where providers of electronic services are required by law to retain data belonging to their subscribers and to activities that are aimed at safeguarding national security and are carried out by the public authorities on their own account, without requiring the cooperation of private parties and not, therefore, imposing obligations on the latter in relation to the management of their businesses.”

The advocate general, moreover, has suggested the indiscriminate retention of all traffic and location data of subscribers and registered users to any particular third-party service is entirely disproportionate.

He has recommended that data retention is targeted and limited to certain categories, with access to this data also limited and subject to approval by a court or independent authority. 

There are a handful of circumstances, however, where Sanchez-Bordona sees no reason why data can’t be retained and accessed on a general basis, for example in the event of intelligence pointing to an immediate threat.

Generally, however, such data collection is not compatible with the general EU privacy rules, and should not be exempted from them over national security grounds.

The preliminary ruling is directly antagonistic to the wishes of various EU governments, including and especially the UK, having argued that legislation such as the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 is necessary to keep citizens safe. 

The act, nicknamed the ‘Snooper’s Charter’, contains provisions for bulk data collection and has been subject to various legal challenges through European courts. The UK has argued that the provisions outlined in the legislation should be exempt from privacy laws.

While the advocate general does not speak for the ECJ, their opinion carries great weight in the process by which decisions are reached. Deliberations have begun, and a judgement will be delivered at a later indeterminate date.

Featured Resources

Navigating the new normal: A fast guide to remote working

A smooth transition will support operations for years to come

Download now

Leading the data race

The trends driving the future of data science

Download now

How to create 1:1 customer experiences at scale

Meet the technology capable of delivering the personalisation your customers crave

Download now

How to achieve daily SAP releases

Accelerate the pace of SAP change to support your digital strategy

Download now

Recommended

ICO to relax GDPR enforcement during coronavirus economic downturn
General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)

ICO to relax GDPR enforcement during coronavirus economic downturn

16 Apr 2020
The NHS teams up with Apple and Google on coronavirus tracking app
privacy

The NHS teams up with Apple and Google on coronavirus tracking app

14 Apr 2020
Health sites are 'unlawfully' sharing medical data with Facebook and Google
data protection

Health sites are 'unlawfully' sharing medical data with Facebook and Google

7 Apr 2020
Supreme Court rules Morrisons was not liable for 2014 data breach
data protection

Supreme Court rules Morrisons was not liable for 2014 data breach

1 Apr 2020

Most Popular

Windows XP source code allegedly leaked online
Microsoft Windows

Windows XP source code allegedly leaked online

25 Sep 2020
16 ways to speed up your laptop
Laptops

16 ways to speed up your laptop

16 Sep 2020
16 ways to speed up your laptop
Laptops

16 ways to speed up your laptop

16 Sep 2020