Microsoft Edge branded as ‘worrisome’ for user privacy

Research claims the web browser sends telemetry data and URLs to back-end servers

Microsoft Edge is one of the least private web browsers, as it sends back device identifiers and web browsing telemetry to back-end servers, according to new research. 

An analysis of the browser, which comes bundled in Windows 10 by default, conducted by  Trinity College Dublin found that Edge sends “persistent identifiers” to back-end services, as well as the URLs typed into the browser’s pages. 

Related Resource

Don’t just collect data, innovate with it.

Removing the barriers to the experience economy

Download now

Professor Douglas Leith from the university’s School of Computer Science and Statistics looked at the behaviour of other browsers as well and concluded that Edge and fellow browser Yandex were lacking in privacy protections. 

“From a privacy perspective Microsoft Edge and Yandex are much more worrisome than the other browsers studied,” Leith explained. “Both send identifiers that are linked to the device hardware and so persist across fresh browser installs and can also be used to link different apps running on the same device. 

“Edge sends the hardware UUID of the device to Microsoft, a strong and enduring identifier than cannot be easily changed or deleted. Similarly, Yandex transmits a hash of the hardware serial number and MAC address to back end servers. 

“As far as we can tell this behaviour cannot be disabled by users. In addition to the search autocomplete functionality (which can be disabled by users) that shares details of web pages visited, both transmit web page information to servers that appear unrelated to search autocomplete.” 

It's worth noting that the collection of user data and browser telemetry isn’t a privacy issue in itself, as such data can facilitate smooth upgrades and feedback when testing new features. But Leith noted that it becomes a problem when such data can be tied to a specific user. 

“When the same identifier is used across multiple transmissions it allows these transmissions to be tied together across time,” Leith said. “While linking data to a browser instance does not explicitly reveal the user’s real-world identity, many studies have shown that location data linked over time can be used to de-anonymize.”

“A second way that issues can arise is when user browsing history is shared with backend servers. Previous studies have shown that it is relatively easy to de-anonymize browsing history, especially when combined with other data,” Leith added. 

Not having the ability to opt-out of such privacy-sapping measures flies in the face of other efforts Microsoft has made in recent times to make its data collection and privacy option in Windows 10 and other services more transparent. 

Conversely, Leith found that the Brave Browser was the most secure, followed by Google’s Chrome browser, Mozilla Firefox, and Apple’s Safari. 

While Microsoft has put in plenty of work to make Edge into an appealing browser, it appears to have more work to do if it wishes to compete with rivals on privacy.

Featured Resources

How to choose an AI vendor

Five key things to look for in an AI vendor

Download now

The UK 2020 Databerg report

Cloud adoption trends in the UK and recommendations for cloud migration

Download now

2021 state of email security report: Ransomware on the rise

Securing the enterprise in the COVID world

Download now

The impact of AWS in the UK

How AWS is powering Britain's fastest-growing companies

Download now

Recommended

How to factory reset Windows 10
operating systems

How to factory reset Windows 10

30 Mar 2021
Microsoft reveals plans for massive cloud expansion in China
data centres

Microsoft reveals plans for massive cloud expansion in China

18 Jun 2021
Windows vs Linux: what's the best operating system?
operating systems

Windows vs Linux: what's the best operating system?

17 Jun 2021
Microsoft's Nadella now holds dual role of CEO and chairman
Careers & training

Microsoft's Nadella now holds dual role of CEO and chairman

17 Jun 2021

Most Popular

How to find RAM speed, size and type
Laptops

How to find RAM speed, size and type

16 Jun 2021
Ten-year-old iOS 4 recreated as an iPhone app
iOS

Ten-year-old iOS 4 recreated as an iPhone app

10 Jun 2021
What is HTTP error 400 and how do you fix it?
Network & Internet

What is HTTP error 400 and how do you fix it?

16 Jun 2021