Government slammed for using Charlie Hebdo attack to revive Snoopers Charter

The ICO and ISPA hit out at Government's attempt to use Paris attacks to push for more surveillance powers

Surveillance

The Government needs to keep a "cool head" about how much access the security services should have to people's private data, in the wake of last week's Paris shootings.

That's according to Christopher Graham, the UK's Information Commissioner, who warned the Government off making any rash decisions about curtailing the use of encrypted online services for surveillance purposes.

"We need cool heads to analyse carefully what information the security services had access to [in the run up to the shootings] and how they used it before necessarily concluding that we must give [the powers that be] access to more and more of our private information," he said during a speech marking the 125th Roscoe Lecture at Liverpool's John Moores University.

"We must avoid knee-jerk reactions. In particular, I am concerned about any compromising of effective encryption for consumers of online services."

His comments follows the news earlier this week about the Prime Minister's plans to stop people using encrypted messaging services, such as WhatsApp and iMessage, on anti-terrorism grounds.

As reported by IT Pro yesterday, David Cameron said he would not hesitate to legislate against the use of these services, should his party remain in power beyond the 2015 General Election.

Graham went on to say that offering encryption to users of online services is an essential step in the fight against cybercrime, but accepts these services could be exploited by people who use them to operate under the radar.

That's why a healthy balance must be struck between protecting the privacy of individuals, and the public interest in keeping tabs on people's online activities.

"In matters of security, we surely need an effective, American-style Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board or the equivalent to find the right balance," he added.

The ICO isn't the only industry body concerned by the push to give the intelligence services greater online surveillance powers since the attack on offices and staff of French satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo.

In a statement, Nicholas Lansman, secretary general for the Internet Service Providers Association (ISPA), said doing so would be the "easy way out" for politicians.

Particularly those intent on using the attacks to make a renewed push to introduce the controversial Communications Data Bill, AKA The Snoopers Charter.

"Existing legislation already allows for suspects' communications to be intercepted via a warrant, and the retention of communications data, which is already being retained in the UK, would also have been available to the intelligence services and the police under the existing RIPA process," Lansman added.

"While the draft Communications Data Bill would have provided access to broader data set, it is questionable whether it would have helped to prevent the incidents in Paris and the industry and UK citizens should be provided with a clear justification for why the Bill is needed now."

Featured Resources

Become a digital service provider

How to transform your business from network core to edge

Download now

Optimal business results with the cloud

Evaluating the best approaches to hybrid cloud adoption

Download now

Virtualisation that enables choices, not compromises

Harness the virtualisation technology that's right for your hybrid infrastructure

Download now

Email security threat report 2020

Four key trends from spear fishing to credentials theft

Download now

Recommended

Should IT departments to call time on WhatsApp?
communications

Should IT departments to call time on WhatsApp?

15 Jan 2021
WhatsApp flaw leaves users open to 'shoulder surfing' attacks
hacking

WhatsApp flaw leaves users open to 'shoulder surfing' attacks

21 Apr 2020
How to build a Raspberry Pi security camera
Hardware

How to build a Raspberry Pi security camera

14 Feb 2020

Most Popular

150,000 arrest records accidentally deleted from police database
data management

150,000 arrest records accidentally deleted from police database

15 Jan 2021
How to recover deleted emails in Gmail
email delivery

How to recover deleted emails in Gmail

6 Jan 2021
What is a 502 bad gateway and how do you fix it?
web hosting

What is a 502 bad gateway and how do you fix it?

12 Jan 2021